Photo credit: www.eater.com
This content originally appeared in an edition of What’s the Difference?, a weekly newsletter created by Brette Warshaw, exploring various topics for those seeking clarity. Eater is set to publish editions that delve into differences in food-related items, contributing to the broader curiosity inherent in the newsletter: Subscribe to receive What’s the Difference? directly in your inbox or view the complete archive.
Understanding Egg Labels
Cage-free, Pasture-raised, Free-range, and Organic Eggs Explained
Entering the egg section of any grocery store can be overwhelming due to the multitude of choices available. Terms such as cage-free, organic, and pasture-raised are everywhere. If you’re concerned about the welfare of the hens or the nutritional value of the eggs, it’s essential to understand that not all eggs come from the same conditions.
The marketing language surrounding eggs can often be confusing, as terms like “cage-free” and “pasture-raised” lack regulation by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) or the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA). In contrast, eggs labeled as organic are produced under strict guidelines, including a diet of organic feed and outdoor access for the hens. Thus, navigating the egg aisle involves some research and awareness of what these labels really signify, especially considering that there isn’t much standard oversight on the actual living conditions of hens used in different egg production systems.
To clarify the diverse claims made on egg cartons, here is a simplified glossary to help you make an informed decision on your next purchase.
Grade A
In American grocery stores, the predominant grade for eggs is Grade A, as defined by the North Carolina Egg Association. This classification indicates that the eggs’ shells are clean, unbroken, and free from deformities. The egg’s interior features firm whites and a yolk that is round and maintains its height. While Grade A represents the second-highest quality of eggs (with Grade AA being superior but rarer), most consumers will typically encounter Grade A eggs on store shelves.
Cage-free
The USDA regulates the term ‘cage-free’, which signifies that the hens are not confined to cages. Instead, they roam freely within an enclosed building or area, enjoying unhindered access to food and water during their production life. However, this designation does not guarantee outdoor access. While cage-free systems may sound better than traditional cages (which are approximately the size of a standard piece of paper), they are not without issues. According to All About Eggs by Rachel Khong, cage-free environments can lead to increased aggression among hens and poorer air quality compared to caged systems.
Free-range
Defined by the USDA, ‘free-range’ implies that hens have some form of outdoor access. However, this doesn’t guarantee that the hens utilize this space, nor does it indicate the quality or size of the outdoor area, which could be limited to a small, fenced-off section. Essentially, it only indicates the existence of a door that could be opened to let hens outside.
Pasture-raised
Though ‘pasture-raised’ is not officially regulated by the USDA, eggs labeled as such that also carry seals like “Certified Humane” or “Animal Welfare Approved” suggest that hens have significant outdoor access—typically around 108 square feet per hen—along with adequate barn space. This label is your best bet for supporting humane production practices when purchasing eggs from larger suppliers.
Organic
The term “organic” is tightly regulated by the USDA’s National Organic Program. Eggs marketed as organic come from hens that are fed a completely organic diet and are raised in settings without cages, ensuring they also have access to the outdoors.
Antibiotic-free (or hormone-free)
The ‘hormone-free’ label indicates that hens were not given hormones, a non-issue since the use of hormones in poultry production has been banned by the FDA. Similarly, the term ‘no added antibiotics’ can be misleading, given that antibiotic use in poultry is highly regulated, and any hens treated with antibiotics are kept from entering human food supply chains.
Vegetarian-fed
Eggs labeled as vegetarian-fed can be deceptive; while chickens may not eat a strictly vegetarian diet in the wild, mass production practices often include animal byproducts in their feed, such as feather meal and chicken litter. Thus, the ‘vegetarian-fed’ label may not always align with what one might expect.
Which egg label should you choose?
Egg cartons bearing the Certified Humane or Animal Welfare Approved seals are generally trustworthy, as these certifications are managed by independent organizations dedicated to animal welfare. Brands such as Vital Farms, Family Homestead, Oliver’s Organic, Happy Egg Co., and Pete and Gerry’s have strong reputations for ethical practices. Similarly, Safeway’s cage-free eggs and Kirkland’s organic eggs from Costco are recognized for their quality.
• What’s the Difference Between Cage-Free, Free-Range, Pasture-Raised, and Organic Eggs? [wtd]
Source
www.eater.com