A Guide to Selecting and Utilizing 9 Popular Varieties

Photo credit: www.seriouseats.com

Oranges offer a vivid splash of color and flavor to our plates, especially in those gloomy weather moments. A bowl of mandarins brightens my kitchen, while orange supremes elevate salads, and the fruit’s innate aroma is a delightful addition to many culinary creations. With over 600 varieties cultivated globally, oranges boast a wide range of sweetness and acidity, making them indispensable in various cuisines, from Moroccan to Mediterranean. Each variety provides distinct characteristics: super sweet mandarins shine when enjoyed fresh, blood oranges add a striking visual to salads, and Valencia oranges are favored for their juicing capabilities. This comprehensive guide will familiarize you with the most common orange types, helping you make informed choices at the grocery store or farmer’s market—and perhaps encourage you to try something new. (The peak seasons mentioned pertain to the U.S.)

Understanding Oranges

While you likely know the basics about oranges, let’s delve deeper. Oranges belong to the Rutaceae family, which encompasses lemons, limes, grapefruit, and more. Their origins trace back to pomelos, citrons, and mandarins—the latter two forming the hybrid that we now enjoy as the orange.

Historical insights from Harold McGee in On Food and Cooking suggest that oranges emerged in areas of southern China, northern India, and Southeast Asia, making their way to Europe by traders and crusaders during the Middle Ages. Today, they thrive in subtropical regions worldwide including Brazil, Mexico, Spain, Japan, and the United States.

Oranges can be broadly categorized into two varieties, in addition to the closely related mandarins.

Sweet oranges (Citrus sinensis) typically have a thicker skin, round shape, and a bold tangy flavor. They excel in raw consumption, baking, or cooking. Sour or bitter oranges (Citrus aurantium) feature a fragrant, thick skin and are characterized by their intensely tart flesh. Meanwhile, Mandarins (Citrus reticulata) encompass tangerines, clementines, and satsumas, which are generally smaller, sweeter, and easier to peel than standard oranges. This guide includes mandarins because they are often found alongside oranges and used interchangeably.

Variety Breakdown

Valencia Orange

Type: Sweet
Flavor: Balanced, sweet with a hint of tartness
Appearance: Oval with a smooth, thin rind of golden-orange hue
Texture: Very juicy flesh
Size: Medium to large, around 3 inches in diameter
Peak Season: March to June

Predominantly cultivated in California and Florida, Valencia oranges are frequently mistaken for originating from Spain. Clarissa Hyman explains in her book Oranges: A History that the name was actually attached in California, inspired by a Spanish traveler nostalgic for an orange variety from his homeland. The United States Department of Agriculture reports that during the 2023 to 2024 season, Valencia oranges held the title of the most produced variety in the U.S., yielding over 944,550 tons.

Unique for their late spring and early summer peak season, Valencia oranges are especially favored for their exquisite juice, which strikes a balance between sweet and tangy, making them a prime choice for fresh juice consumption or culinary uses.

Navel Orange

Type: Sweet
Flavor: Sweet, aromatic with mild acidity
Appearance: Rounded to slightly oval with a noticeable navel on one end; bright orange and pebbled skin; yellow-orange flesh
Texture: Juicy with tender flesh and thin membranes
Size: Medium to large, from 3 to 4 inches in diameter
Peak Season: November to February

Hailing from Brazil, navel oranges are one of the most common varieties across the U.S., distinguished by their noticeable navel-like feature at the stem end. Among them, the Cara Cara is becoming increasingly popular due to its pink flesh and lower acidity.

They possess a thinner skin compared to many other varieties and are sweet, seedless fruits. As Valerie Aikman-Smith notes, “They’re the standard everybody knows and eats. You can always expect sweetness and juiciness.”

Since navel oranges do not produce seeds, propagation involves grafting techniques requiring careful management to ensure fruitful yields. This method is labor-intensive and can make large-scale orange production more complex due to slower tree maturation and greater disease susceptibility.

Perfect for snacking or enhancing salads, navel oranges are juicy, but be mindful: an antioxidant named limonin creates a bitter taste in the juice about 30 minutes post-exposure to air. Hence, it’s best to consume the juice immediately after extraction.

Blood Orange

Type: Sweet
Flavor: Floral with sweet-tart complexity and notes reminiscent of raspberries
Appearance: Globose with a reddish-orange rind and strikingly dark red flesh
Texture: Medium-thick pulp and juicy flesh
Size: Medium to large, around 2 to 3 inches in diameter
Peak Season: December to April

The blood orange, a hybrid of a pomelo and tangerine, boasts ruby-red flesh and captivating floral notes, originating from the southern Mediterranean. Popular varieties include the arancia rossa di Sicilia, sanguinello moscata, and moro, providing distinct taste profiles varying in sweetness and tartness. The reddish hue is attributed to anthocyanins, which also color other fruits and vegetables like blueberries and beets.

Aikman-Smith characterizes the blood orange as offering a mildly tart yet fragrant profile with subtle hints of cherry and raspberry. Typically with few seeds, blood oranges are excellent in salads and their juice makes a refreshing addition to cocktails.

Seville Orange

Type: Sour
Flavor: Bitter rind with intensely sour flesh
Appearance: Round featuring a bumpy, thick yellow-orange skin; orange interior
Texture: Soft, juicy flesh with a spongy pith and cream-colored seeds
Size: Medium, around 3 inches in diameter
Peak Season: January through March

Known as bitter oranges, Seville oranges are high in acidity and not typically eaten raw. Instead, they are a culinary staple in regions like Spain, where they enhance dishes like cochinita pibil—Yucatán-style barbecued pork—and sangria, thanks to their vinegar-like acidity. Their high pectin levels also make them superb for marmalades; when balanced with sugar, their sour notes bring layers of flavor to spreads.

Mandarin

Type: Mandarin
Flavor: Sweet and robust
Appearance: Deep orange, spherical in shape
Texture: Soft flesh with loose peelable skin
Size: Small to medium, ranging from 1 1/2 to 3 inches in diameter
Peak Season: November through March

Known for their bright, sweet, and slightly tangy flavor, mandarins include clementines and satsumas, which are often just labeled as “mandarin.” These fruits typically offer a sweeter and less acidic profile, making them a popular fresh snack, especially during the Chinese Lunar New Year, where their bright color symbolizes prosperity. With nearly 200 varieties in existence, mandarins exhibit remarkably easy peelable skin and often are virtually seedless.

Tangerine

Type: Mandarin
Flavor: Robustly sweet-tart
Appearance: Round, slightly flattened with a bright orange-red hue
Texture: Thin, smooth peel enveloping juicy flesh with cream-colored seeds
Size: Small to medium, from 2 1/2 to 3 inches in diameter
Peak Season: November through March

Tangerines, which fall under the mandarin category, have a dimpled exterior and contain a sweet, tangy flesh. They gained popularity in the U.S. in the 19th century following their introduction by Italian immigrants from Tangiers, Morocco. While many tangerines contain seeds, hybrids such as clementines and tangelos are commonly seedless, ensuring ease and convenience for snacking.

Clementine

Type: Mandarin
Flavor: Sweet with subtle floral notes and slight tanginess
Appearance: Round with smooth, shiny orange skin that is slightly flattened
Texture: Juicy, tender flesh with minimal pith
Size: Small, around 1 1/2 to 2 inches in diameter
Peak Season: November through January

As the smallest type of mandarin, clementines are frequently marketed under labels such as Cuties, Sweeties, or Halos. Their sweetness, seedlessness, and ease of peeling make them a favored option for those seeking a refreshing snack.

Satsuma

Type: Mandarin
Flavor: Mild with honeyed sweet notes and light acidity
Appearance: Round with a slightly flattened shape and a subtle hue compared to other mandarins
Texture: Smooth rind encasing juicy flesh with minimal pith
Size: Small to medium, measuring between 2 1/2 to 4 inches in diameter
Peak Season: October through December

Satsumas are characterized by their flatter profile and bumpy rinds, making them easy to peel and sweet with a hint of acidity. Generally seedless in stores, homegrown varieties may contain seeds. They are often consumed fresh but also find usage in canning recipes.

With over 100 varieties, including the common miyagawa from Japan and xie shan from China, most satsumas in the U.S. are of the variety known as owari. Notably, satsumas exhibit resilience against cooler temperatures compared to other citrus fruits, thriving in conditions that are generally unfavorable for orange cultivation.

Sumo Citrus

Type: Mandarin
Flavor: Balanced and fruity with a refreshing sweetness and tangy notes
Appearance: Round to oval with a notable knob on top and yellow-orange skin
Texture: Bumpy rind and firm, succulent flesh with minimal pith
Size: Medium to large, about 3 to 4 inches in diameter
Peak Season: January through April

Created in 1972 through the crossing of a tangor and a ponkan, the Sumo Citrus—or Dekopon in Japan—has garnered attention for its size, flavor, and quality. The name evokes its typical large size and the distinctive bump resembling a traditional Japanese topknot.

Cultivation of Sumo Citrus is labor-intensive, contributing to its higher price point. The trees require approximately four years after grafting before fruiting, and each fruit undergoes a careful hand-picking process. Post-harvest, Sumo Citrus is cured for 20 to 40 days to enhance sweetness by decreasing acidity and allowing natural moisture redistribution, creating both flavorful fruit and easy peeling.

Selecting Quality Oranges and Mandarins

Generally, Aikman-Smith advises looking for oranges that are glossy, firm, and exhibit a slight give. Quality fruits should have no blemishes or bruises, which can indicate spoilage. While a vibrant orange hue can signal ripeness, it isn’t the sole determinant of quality; the fruit’s weight and fragrance are better indicators. A heavy feel and fresh citrus scent can suggest juiciness and flavor potential.

Commercial oranges are often harvested prematurely to maintain firmness for transport. However, this practice inhibits the development of the fruit’s characteristic aroma and sweetness, resulting in less fragrant and flavorful fruit.

The citrus season generally runs from November to June, although Valencia oranges peak in early summer. Aikman-Smith points out that purchasing in-season fruit increases the likelihood of buying fresher produce—especially in regions where oranges are grown. In contrast, obtaining fruit out of season typically means it was stored or shipped from far away, impacting quality.

Visiting local orchards for citrus picking can yield the freshest fruits, and choosing farmers’ markets with regionally sourced produce often results in superior flavor. If you reside in areas without citrus production, seek vendors known for high-quality selections.

Culinary Uses of Oranges

While enjoying oranges and mandarins raw is popular, cooking can amplify their sweetness and blend their acidity, imparting a bright citrus flavor to various dishes. It’s essential to balance their sugars and acidity in cooking to harmonize with other ingredients. Certain recipes that require depth of flavor, like sauces or baked goods, may necessitate a specific orange type. Dishes such as salads or frozen treats allow for broader experimentation with different varieties, each contributing unique characteristics.

Fresh Juice

Valencia oranges, with their thin skin and nearly seedless pulp, are favored for juicing. Their juice can be enjoyed as is or incorporated into beverages, sauces, smoothies, and dressings. Blood orange juice provides an appealing color and refreshing taste for various applications. Freezing juice during peak harvest times allows for later use when needed.

Marinade, Sauce, and Braising Liquid

The citric acid in orange juice makes it a powerful marinade, enhancing flavor while tenderizing meats through the breakdown of proteins. Seville oranges, with their sharper acidity, are particularly adept for traditional dishes like Cuban mojo pork and French duck à l’orange, where balancing sweetness and sourness is crucial.

Segments

Sweet oranges can be cut into segments for salads or ceviches. Firmer varieties such as Valencia retain their shape well, enhancing dishes. Although segmenting smaller mandarins may be trickier, their low pith content allows for easy peeling and separation for salads.

Zest

Incorporating orange zest lends a refreshing lightness to heavier dishes. Aikman-Smith notably suggests using navel orange zest in gremolata as a flavorful accompaniment for lamb or osso buco, while zest can enhance salads, vinaigrettes, desserts, and orange curd with its vibrant aroma.

Preserves

Due to their rich pectin content, Seville oranges are often selected for making marmalade. Mandarins, with their delightful sweetness, are also excellent for preserving.

Baked Desserts

Sweet orange juice enhances desserts like tarts and crème brûlée. Sour oranges work brilliantly in orange meringue pie to contrast sweetness or can substitute for key lime pie. Whole pieces of satsumas can be folded into cake batters, or caramelized oranges can provide a luxurious topping for desserts like cheesecake.

Shelf Life of Oranges

Oranges maintain quality for a short while at room temperature, but consuming them within a few days is preferable as they lose freshness over time. Refrigerated oranges can last up to three weeks, primarily if stored in the crisper drawer. Avoid sealing them in plastic bags to prevent premature softening and potential molding. Orange juice, on the other hand, can be frozen and maintain quality for up to six months.

Source
www.seriouseats.com