Photo credit: www.kiplinger.com
The Evolving Perspective on Annuities in Retirement Planning
Annuities provide a form of guaranteed income that can bring a sense of security during retirement. They ensure that individuals receive a consistent payment, irrespective of fluctuations in the stock market. However, the question arises: are annuities essential for everyone?
The stance on annuities appears to be shifting. A recent study by Cerulli Associates, a research firm focused on wealth and asset management, surveyed asset managers regarding their opinions on retirement income solutions. In 2019, 42% felt that an effective retirement strategy required a guaranteed income component, whereas this number dropped to 37% by 2024, indicating a growing skepticism about their necessity.
The Impact of SECURE Act 2.0
The evolving sentiment coincides with recent changes that allow for the incorporation of annuities in 401(k) plans, following the enactment of SECURE Act 2.0 at the end of 2022. This legislation aims to facilitate a reliable income stream for retirees through annuities within their retirement accounts.
Despite their potential benefits, some financial advisors and retirees express concerns about the complexities, costs, and restrictions associated with annuities. Idin Eftekhari, a senior analyst at Cerulli, highlights that recent survey results reflect an increasing ambivalence about whether annuities are truly a necessity, with many seeing them as optional rather than essential.
Assessing the Tradeoffs: Liquidity Concerns
A major drawback of annuities is the liquidity issue. To fund an annuity, individuals typically need to make a lump sum payment or a series of contributions, which are then unavailable for withdrawal without incurring penalties once the initial cancellation period has passed. This lack of access to capital can be problematic if unexpected expenses arise during retirement, forcing individuals to deplete other savings to meet their financial needs.
Moreover, Eftekhari points out that many annuities do not adjust for inflation, potentially diminishing their value over time. While some options provide inflation protection, they often come with higher costs. “If retirement participants were fully informed about what they were purchasing, many might reconsider,” Eftekhari asserts.
Understanding Annuity Fees
The fees associated with annuities also warrant careful consideration. Depending on specific features, these fees can range from 1.5% to 4%, making it challenging for investors to gauge their true cost, particularly within a 401(k) setting. Over time, these fees can significantly erode potential returns. Jane Delashmutt O’Mara, a certified financial planner, notes that any product promising guarantees typically carries a cost, emphasizing the importance of comprehensively understanding these expenses.
That said, annuities may still be a viable option for particular individuals such as those seeking to qualify for Medicaid or individuals with significant cash windfalls who prefer to avoid market volatility. O’Mara recommends that annuities should complement a broader financial strategy rather than serve as the sole solution. For instance, constructing a bond portfolio can yield predictable income throughout retirement, providing an alternative to annuity investments.
Recognizing the Role of Guaranteed Income
According to Rick Sweeney, director of insured solutions at RBC Wealth Management, there is a noticeable concern among clients regarding the longevity of their savings. Many opt for annuities as a safeguard against outliving their resources, and they often integrate these products into a diversified income strategy that encompasses multiple revenue streams.
However, Eftekhari cautions that not everyone is suited for annuities. The complexity of these contracts often means that individuals may overlook significant details during the sign-up process, leading to misunderstandings about what they are committing to.
Adopting a Comprehensive Financial Strategy
A well-rounded approach may serve retirees best, combining various income sources. Boldin, a firm specializing in financial planning software, reports that out of their 41,000 subscribers, about 3,000 households have all their retirement expenses covered by guaranteed income streams. The average coverage stands at 54%, largely derived from Social Security, pensions, and annuities.
“Individuals aim to have sufficient guaranteed income to meet essential expenses while utilizing investment portfolios for discretionary spending and leisure activities,” explains Nancy Gates, lead educator and financial coach at Boldin. Crafting a tailored financial plan that accounts for personal circumstances is crucial for long-term security in retirement.
Related Content
Source
www.kiplinger.com