Photo credit: www.bbc.com

Embracing Positional Football: A Shift in the Game

Criticism of positional football often stems from frustration, leading some to conclude, “If we can’t do it well, let’s abandon it.” However, this mindset overlooks the nature of progress in sports. The fact that only a select few teams currently excel at this style does not indicate a flaw in the system; rather, it reflects a transitional phase in football. The focus should not be on declaring it ineffective, but rather on exploring ways to enhance its implementation.

Nostalgia for the past can skew perceptions, creating the illusion that football was once more spontaneous and authentic. In reality, today’s game is an evolution, marked by increased complexity, teamwork, and strategic design. While this approach poses greater challenges for coaching and gameplay, it also offers a unique beauty when executed well.

This evolution is exemplified by managers like Unai Emery, who have redefined their philosophies by studying the game’s development. Emery has embraced positional principles for practical reasons, seeking enhanced control, clarity, and consistency, regardless of the caliber of players at his disposal. This adaptability is commendable, as not every coach—or player—can make such a leap.

Why should defenders such as Virgil van Dijk, Pau Torres, or Pau Cubarsi not have as much involvement in ball distribution as midfielders? Why can’t they serve as playmakers or inspire a new generation of defenders through their contributions?

Even Paris Saint-Germain, a club traditionally known for individual talent, has begun integrating positional concepts into their attacking strategies. They emphasize pressing immediately after losing possession, showcasing a willingness to evolve.

Imagining the future of football is one of its greatest challenges, akin to life itself; it’s often easier to yearn for the past and claim it was superior. While the specifics of football in ten years remain uncertain, the growing consensus is that positional play is not only relevant now but will continue to shape the sport.

As we find ourselves in a significant cultural transformation within football, some coaches strive to replicate this model, with varying degrees of success, while others are still navigating the learning curve. A few remain resistant. Nonetheless, it’s likely that within five years, most teams will incorporate some elements of positional football—not out of obligation, but because the sport evolves too swiftly for those unwilling to adapt.

The upcoming generation of coaches is increasingly versed in this approach, suggesting that it could soon become the norm across clubs. We’re not expecting every team to achieve Michelin-star quality, but we do advocate for progress away from outdated practices.

Rather than resist this model, we should appreciate the journey it entails. Let’s acknowledge the teams striving for the right balance between tactical structure and cultural identity, rather than dismiss them simply because they do not mirror Guardiola’s Manchester City.

A new football culture is emerging, and it appears to be here to stay.

Source
www.bbc.com