Photo credit: news.un.org
Haiti’s Independence: The Ongoing Impact of a Historical Debt
Haiti is renowned as the first nation to liberate itself from slavery through a successful revolt, achieving independence from France in 1804. However, this monumental act of defiance against colonialism came with severe consequences. On April 17, 1825, facing a blockade from French warships, Haiti agreed to pay an indemnity of 150 million gold francs to France.
Officially, this indemnity was purportedly compensation for “lost property” incurred by French plantation owners post-independence, yet the figure dwarfed any actual losses. As noted by Monique Clesca, a journalist and activist of Haitian descent, during a recent meeting concerning Haiti’s historical debt at the UN Permanent Forum on People of African Descent, France forced Haiti—once the estate of enslaved individuals—into compensating their former colonial rulers.
The Cost of Freedom: A Dual Burden
This financial burden on this fledgling republic rapidly escalated, leading Haiti into a cycle of debt. As the country struggled to meet its obligations, French banks intervened, requiring additional loans, a scenario Clesca described as a “double debt.”
By 1914, over three-quarters of Haiti’s national budget was dedicated to repaying these loans, a situation that persisted until 1947—more than a century after independence—when Haiti finally settled its obligations to France.
“The immense injustice imposed by France continues to echo in our times,” Clesca emphasized.
According to a comprehensive investigation published in 2022 by The New York Times, Haiti’s payments to France would translate to the modern equivalent of about $560 million. Economists suggest that had these funds been retained within Haiti, they could have significantly boosted economic growth, potentially adding over $20 billion to the country’s financial landscape over the years.
Haiti Today: The Legacy of Historical Debt
Despite its role as a symbol in the global struggle for freedom, Haiti currently faces profound instability, with armed gangs reportedly controlling approximately 85 percent of its capital, Port-au-Prince. The World Bank lists Haiti as the poorest nation in Latin America and the Caribbean, grappling with multifaceted challenges ranging from institutional dysfunction to rampant corruption and arms trafficking.
During discussions at the UN Permanent Forum, participants highlighted that many of Haiti’s current crises are rooted in its historical context. “The deep-seated human rights violations in Haiti are intrinsically linked to the legacies of slavery, colonialism, and ongoing debt payments,” articulated the advisory body to the UN Human Rights Council in a recent position paper.
A Long-Awaited Recognition
In response to growing demands for accountability, French President Emmanuel Macron recently announced the establishment of a joint commission involving Haitian and French historians to evaluate the consequences of the 1825 indemnity.
While this initiative was welcomed by participants such as Martin Kimani, a member of the Permanent Forum, concerns were raised regarding the commission’s capacity to fully acknowledge the historical harm that has transpired. “We advocate for the restitution of the funds taken through this cost arrangement, along with more extensive reparative measures to rectify Haiti’s ongoing underdevelopment and the lack of international support,” Kimani asserted during the Forum’s closing discussions.
Reports indicate that President Macron has not yet committed to providing direct financial reparations.
Advocacy for Restitution
“The burden of our colonial past imposes collective responsibilities on both France and the international community,” stated Pierre Ericq Pierre, Haiti’s Permanent Representative to the UN. He underscored that Haiti’s continuing socioeconomic disparities stem from its colonial history and the burdensome “ransom.”
He emphasized that pursuing restitution is a matter of fairness, saying, “This isn’t about vengeance; it’s about justice and acknowledgment of truth.”
Pursuing Restorative Justice
Haitians aspire to a future free from violence and aligned with essential standards for progress, as articulated by Gaynel Curry, another member of the Permanent Forum. She advocated for the return of the colonial debt, in addition to establishing an international reparations fund for Haiti and launching an independent inquiry by the Human Rights Council that focuses on pathways toward restorative justice.
Verene Albertha Shepherd, Vice Chair of the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination, reinforced that fulfilling these obligations would honor a deeper commitment—one owed by those of African descent to the revolutionaries of Haiti. “These freedom fighters instilled fear in all slaveholders,” she noted, stressing that over two hundred years post-independence, the urgency for justice has never been greater.
Source
news.un.org