Photo credit: www.cbsnews.com
Investigation Uncovers Flaws in Titan Submersible’s Design
Recent testimonies from engineers involved in the investigation of the Titan submersible tragedy have revealed critical information about the vessel’s construction and operational history. The experimental submersible, which imploded while descending to the Titanic wreck in June 2023, exhibited manufacturing defects linked to its carbon fiber hull. Don Kramer from the National Transportation Safety Board indicated that these flaws resulted in structural vulnerabilities that likely contributed to the catastrophic failure.
Kramer highlighted the presence of wrinkles, porosity, and voids in the carbon fiber material, as well as damage observed after a “loud acoustic event” recorded during a previous dive in July 2022. The failure of the hull was further confirmed when pieces recovered post-implosion showed significant delamination, implying a breakdown of the hull’s structural integrity.
OceanGate’s co-founder, Stockton Rush, was among the five individuals who perished in the incident. His actions leading up to the tragedy are now under scrutiny, especially regarding the operational risks associated with the Titan’s design.
Criticism from Industry Experts
William Kohnen, a veteran in submersible technology and a notable critic of OceanGate, addressed a panel on Wednesday, expressing his concerns over the company’s reluctance to broaden its safety protocols. Kohnen contended that despite the Titan being labeled as experimental, thorough testing could have been conducted prior to its operational deployment. He argued that many in the industry were hesitant to challenge Rush’s decisions, leading to a culture where rigorous scrutiny was avoided.
“I don’t think many people ever told Stockton no,” Kohnen said, stressing the dire implications of such an environment. He conveyed that the intentions of the industry were not to deter innovation, but to ensure safety standards were met.
The Coast Guard initiated a public hearing this month as part of an extensive investigation into the circumstances surrounding the implosion. The focus has been split between the submersible’s atypical carbon fiber construction and the troubling operational history of OceanGate.
Bart Kemper, another expert called to testify, expressed specific concerns about the submersible’s window, indicating it showed signs that aligned with structural failure. This testimony, coupled with previous comments made by former OceanGate operations director David Lochridge, paints a picture of a company eager to push its boundaries without adhering to conventional safety measures.
A Broader Discussion on Deep-Sea Exploration
During the hearing, Karl Stanley, a submersible pilot and designer, offered insight into the expectations surrounding deep-sea operational safety. Stanley asserted that the implosion was a foreseeable outcome for those familiar with the submersible’s operational standards, suggesting that the unfortunate event could have been avoided with proper oversight.
In the aftermath of the disaster, some voices within OceanGate, like co-founder Guillermo Sohnlein, expressed hope that the tragedy would serve to rekindle interest in underwater exploration, despite the loss of life.
As the hearings progress, testimonies are expected from other past associates of OceanGate, shedding light on the company’s dynamics and decision-making processes. The submersible’s final dive on June 18, 2023, ended with a message from the crew stating, “all good here,” shortly before losing communication, showcasing a troubling contrast against the ensuing catastrophe.
Efforts to locate the wreckage of the Titan revealed that it was found approximately 330 yards away from the Titanic’s bow, marking a grim conclusion to an ambitious endeavor in deep-sea exploration. The Coast Guard confirmed that there were no survivors among the five individuals on board, including renowned Titanic expert Paul-Henri Nargeolet.
The ramifications of the implosion extend beyond the immediate loss; families of the victims are now pursuing accountability, with Nargeolet’s family filing a wrongful death lawsuit against OceanGate, seeking redress for their profound loss.
This series of hearings continues to evolve, promising to address not only the events leading to the Titan’s demise but also the future of private ventures in undersea exploration.
Source
www.cbsnews.com