Photo credit: www.news18.com
Controversy Surrounding Salim-Javed: Accusations of Plagiarism
Amit Aaryan Challenges Bollywood Legends
The 1970s are often regarded as a golden era for Bollywood, largely due to the impactful storytelling and iconic films shaped by the renowned writing duo Salim-Javed. However, Amit Aaryan, noted for his work on television series such as FIR and Yeh Un Dinon Ki Baat Hai, has stirred controversy by accusing the celebrated screenwriters of plagiarism rather than originality in their work.
In a candid interview with Digital Commentary, Aaryan expressed his views about the legacy of Salim Khan and Javed Akhtar. He stated, “I do not consider Salim and Javed writers. They are two people whom the whole world salutes, but they have only, in their entire lives, plagiarised. Salim and Javed are copy-writers, not writers.” To support his allegations, Aaryan pointed to the iconic 1975 film Sholay, asserting that it drew substantial inspiration from Raj Khosla’s 1971 film Mera Gaon Mera Desh.
Aaryan elaborated on the similarities he perceives between the two films. He described the central theme of revenge against a dacoit, highlighting character parallels such as that of Gabbar Singh from Sholay and Jabbar Singh from Mera Gaon Mera Desh. He noted other character similarities, including a retired soldier with a disabled arm in Khosla’s film, which he claims has a counterpart among the characters in Sholay.
Moreover, Aaryan extended his critique to various other works of Salim-Javed, including the film Deewaar. He asserted that Deewaar borrowed heavily from the earlier movie Gunga Jumna. The writer expressed that the duo has a tendency to recycle previous storylines, citing examples from their own repertoire and suggesting that their actions lean more towards savvy commercialization rather than genuine creativity. “Salim and Javed are better businessmen and salesmen. They knew how to sell something and narrate it well,” Aaryan remarked.
Notably, despite these serious claims, Aaryan recalled a positive experience with Salim Khan, stating that Khan appreciated the television series FIR and expressed his admiration by inviting the cast to dine with his family. He also mentioned the recent documentary Angry Young Men, which he suggested was an attempt by the offspring of Salim and Javed to enhance their parents’ public image.
This documentary, available on Amazon Prime Video, spans three episodes and compiles various anecdotes about the legendary writing duo. It has been described by News18 Showsha as a balanced tribute to their career, noting, “Directed by Namrata Rao, this three-part series isn’t just a tribute but an exploration of their professional brilliance and personal complexities, showcasing the men who revolutionised Hindi cinema.”
The series delves into the dynamic between Salim and Javed, discussing their financial dealings, major successes, professional challenges, and eventual split. Additionally, it offers insights into their personal lives, touching on their respective marriages.
Source
www.news18.com