Photo credit: hechingerreport.org

The Future of ERIC: Navigating Challenges in Educational Research Access

When searching for educational research—be it on four-day school weeks, teaching methodologies, or historical documents such as the Coleman Report—many may turn to Google. What many do not realize is that high-quality search results often stem from a vital resource called ERIC.

ERIC, an acronym for the Education Resources Information Center, functions as a comprehensive online library housing approximately 2.1 million educational documents. Funded and operated by the U.S. Department of Education, this collection has its roots in the 1960s and was originally disseminated through microfiche. Today, it serves as an open-access platform where anyone can explore, read, or download documents without needing a library card or login. With an estimated 14 million users annually, ERIC stands as a crucial academic resource, comparable to MedLine or PubMed in the healthcare sector.

Notably, this significant online library is expected to continue its operation under a five-year contract that extends through 2028. However, it was announced earlier this year that ERIC would be affected by the Department of Government Efficiency’s (DOGE) decisions regarding budget operations. Erin Pollard Young, the last employee at the Education Department overseeing ERIC, indicated that subsequent to her departure, DOGE halted the disbursement of funds already approved by Congress, jeopardizing the future of this essential resource.

Related: Our free weekly newsletter alerts you to what research says about schools and classrooms.

As a result, funds for ERIC are projected to run out by April 23, effectively halting the addition of new documents. Pollard Young expressed her concerns, stating, “After 60 years of gathering hard-to-find education literature and sharing it broadly, the website could stop being updated.” While the existing data may remain for some time, the absence of regular updates would lead to a significant loss of information.

The potential defunding of ERIC has raised concerns among various stakeholders, including parents, educators, and policy makers. Gladys Cruz, a superintendent of Questar III BOCES in New York, articulated that cutting funding for ERIC would severely restrict public access to vital educational research, ultimately impairing evidence-based practices and informed policy-making essential for enhancing the American education system.

Budget Cuts and Consequences

Pollard Young revealed that prior to her exit from the Education Department, she was engaged in attempts to address a DOGE mandate requiring a substantial reduction in ERIC’s budget—from $5.5 million to $2.25 million. Such budget cuts would necessitate the elimination of 45 percent of the journals added to the database annually, in addition to closing the public help desk. Furthermore, she was prepared to personally manage communications with 1,500 publishers, a task previously handled by AEM Education Services, which is responsible for managing education data for the government.

Despite these efforts, Pollard Young received a terse communication from DOGE conveyed entirely in uppercase letters: “THIS IS NOT APPROVED,” followed by a request for further justification. She supplied this information but received no additional feedback before losing her access to work emails just days later during a mass layoff affecting over 1,300 Education Department employees.

Expanding the Scope of ERIC

Pollard Young’s role involved daily management of ERIC alongside a team of 30 contractors from AEM Education Services. The process of cataloging new documents is meticulous, involving the evaluation of significance and the addition of descriptive metadata that enhances discoverability in search engines like Google. However, the public can directly search ERIC’s database as well.

Opinions within the educational community further underscore the importance of ERIC. Paige Kowalski from the Data Quality Campaign noted the website’s reliability, stating that despite encountering poorly designed websites over the years, she could consistently locate her resources through ERIC.

The collection features a wealth of academic journal articles, many available as full-text PDFs otherwise hidden behind paywalls. ERIC is also home to a variety of resources, including government documents and doctoral dissertations.

The Importance of “Gray Literature”

A distinctive aspect of ERIC is its significant collection of “gray literature”—research studies and reports that are not published in traditional academic journals or indexed in private databases like EBSCO. Pollard Young emphasized the critical nature of these resources, indicating, “In education, so much research is produced outside of journals, and significant randomized controlled trials can often be found in white papers or special reports.” This underlines why ERIC’s curated collection remains indispensable, beyond what Google or AI can replicate.

In its response regarding ERIC’s future, the Department of Education highlighted a broader initiative to restructure the Institute of Education Sciences (IES), which oversees ERIC. Madi Biedermann, the deputy assistant secretary for communications, pointed out that despite considerable financial investment, IES has not effectively delivered on its educational improvement goals. The Department is currently examining how to restructure IES to enhance its utility for states while ensuring scientific rigor and cost-effectiveness.

There remains hope that DOGE might approve the reduced budget proposal imminently, potentially averting a complete shutdown of ERIC operations. Nevertheless, without a dedicated staff to oversee its management and publisher communications, the future of ERIC appears precarious. Pollard Young conveyed that under the best-case scenario, ERIC would continue to function at half of its previous budget.

A Call to Action

Like her colleagues laid off in March, Pollard Young is currently on administrative leave until June. Nonetheless, she has expressed her readiness to publicly advocate for the preservation of ERIC, despite potential repercussions. “It is essential for the field to know that I am doing everything in my power to save ERIC, and for the public to understand the situation. Conversations with individuals nationwide show a lack of awareness about developments occurring in D.C.,” she stated, hoping to galvanize support to sustain ERIC’s funding.

Source
hechingerreport.org