Photo credit: www.sciencedaily.com
Reconstructing Ancient Diets: New Insights from Isotope Analysis
Understanding the evolution of herbivores and carnivores opens a window into ancient ecosystems and the dietary habits of extinct species. While observing current animals allows researchers to infer their food preferences, the diets of extinct vertebrates require a different approach. A recent study led by Professor Thomas Tütken at Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz (JGU) has established a reference framework using isotope compositions that could offer valuable insights for inferring the diets of ancient reptiles. This significant research was published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B.
Diverse Dietary Preferences Among Modern Reptiles
Reptiles today showcase an extensive range of dietary habits. Some species are strict herbivores, while others are obligate carnivores. For instance, the marine iguana subsists on algae, chameleons exclusively eat insects, and apex predators like the saltwater crocodile thrive on meat. This diversity complicates the task of reconstructing the diets of extinct reptiles, noted Tütken, who describes the challenge faced by paleontologists in understanding the nutritional habits of these ancient beings.
The lineage of modern reptiles dates back over 300 million years. The earliest known reptilian ancestor, Hylonomus, emerged approximately 315 million years ago and exhibited morphological features suggesting it may have been insectivorous. However, the timeline for the dietary transition from insects to a broader range encompassing both carnivory and herbivory remains ambiguous.
A New Geochemical Framework
Tütken and his team have created a geochemical reference framework based on the analysis of 28 extant reptile species, which serves as a basis for understanding both living and extinct vertebrate dietary patterns. By investigating the calcium and strontium isotopes within the bones and teeth of these reptiles, the team can differentiate diets systematically. “We selected species that represent notable herbivorous or carnivorous behaviors to create a comprehensive comparative dataset,” Tütken explained.
Particularly focusing on the calcium isotopes calcium-44 and calcium-42, the research found a consistent decline in these isotopes as one moves up the food chain, distinguishing insectivores from herbivores and carnivores. Dr. Michael Weber, a lead author of the study, emphasized the notable differentiation in isotope ratios among these dietary groups, especially highlighting the unique dietary habits of certain species like marine iguanas and egg-eating reptiles.
The team also established a stable strontium isotope reference system to provide more detailed dietary insights. Dr. Katrin Weber, co-author of the study, highlighted that while strontium isotopes reveal consistent nutrition patterns, the calcium isotopes offer a clearer pathway for examining extinct species, given the complications of using strontium related to fossil preservation.
Comparative analysis between reptilian and mammalian calcium isotope ratios indicated that reptiles exhibit a broader range of ratios, a finding attributed to physiological differences that suggests caution when applying mammalian data to prehistoric reptiles’ dietary assessments.
Additive Insights from Mechanical Wear Patterns
The study encompassed additional analysis of mechanical wear patterns on teeth, which provided supplementary information regarding dietary tendencies. By examining tooth wear, researchers can infer whether an animal favored hard or soft foods, thus enriching their understanding of ancient diets. The collaboration with Dr. Daniela Winkler allowed for a detailed examination of the teeth of modern reptiles alongside the new isotopic data, creating a robust dataset for dietary reconstruction.
“The integration of chemical and mechanical data offers a precise framework for evaluating the nutritional behaviors of extinct species,” Tütken concluded. His prior research into the diets of the first land vertebrates, supported by an ERC Consolidator Grant, laid the groundwork for this important new study into the feeding habits of ancient reptiles.
Source
www.sciencedaily.com