How Effectively Did the Enigmatic Antikythera Mechanism Function?

Photo credit: www.smithsonianmag.com

Historians theorize that the ancient device was designed to forecast celestial movements. New research indicates its mechanisms may have frequently faced operational issues.

Sonja Anderson – Daily Correspondent

In 1900, sponge divers stumbled upon a shipwreck near the Greek island of Antikythera, unveiling the remains of a cargo ship from over 2,000 years ago, along with a treasure trove of historical artifacts. The excavation unearthed numerous items including coins, jewelry, glassware, a monumental statue of Hercules, and three life-sized marble horses. However, the site’s most remarkable discovery is the enigmatic Antikythera mechanism.

Researchers believe that the gears were capable of predicting the positions of the sun, moon, and several planets, as well as forecasting solar and lunar eclipses. Jo Marchant, author of the book Decoding the Heavens: Solving the Mystery of the World’s First Computer, explained that the dials and inscriptions provided users with essential information about celestial happenings.

A recent study conducted by engineers Esteban Szigety and Gustavo Arenas from the National University of Mar del Plata in Argentina suggests that the Antikythera mechanism may not have functioned effectively.

Szigety and Arenas describe the device as a “toy prone to constant jamming,” likening its issues to those of a modern printer that frequently malfunctions. They found that the machinery could only be operated correctly for about four months into the future before it became jammed or the gears disengaged, necessitating a complete reset from the user.

The researchers developed a virtual model of the mechanism, taking into consideration earlier studies that highlighted flaws in the alignment of its gears. Notably, astrophysicist Michael Edmunds pointed out these issues back in 2006, speculating that the device might have served more as a visual or educational tool rather than a practical astronomical calculator.

According to Szigety, if the errors identified in previous research are accurate, the mechanism would have been rendered ineffective, potentially jamming with a single gear moving while another remained stationary. However, Szigety posits that it is improbable the device was completely non-functional. He wonders how such an intricate machine could be developed without operation as a final goal.

Edmunds responds, emphasizing that even if one assumes the device could be made to work within certain constraints, it does not alter the overarching conclusion that the lunar pointer was not highly reliable in its predictions.

The Antikythera mechanism has been housed in Athens’ National Archaeological Museum for many years, captivating visitors with its intricate history. After two millennia submerged in water, the original bronze has deteriorated into a brittle mineral known as atacamite, complicating efforts to ascertain the exact dimensions and functionalities of its parts.

Aristeidis Voulgaris, an expert from the Thessaloniki Directorate of Culture and Tourism in Greece, notes that any modern attempts to measure the gears must take into account the distortions caused by degradation. This limitation means that definitive claims about the device’s functionality remain elusive.

Source
www.smithsonianmag.com