Photo credit: www.sciencedaily.com

Understanding the Alarming Decline of Global Insect Populations

The alarming rate at which insect populations are disappearing worldwide has raised significant concerns among scientists and conservationists alike. While agricultural intensification is frequently cited as a leading cause, a new study by researchers at Binghamton University, State University of New York, suggests that the reasons behind this decline are much more complex and interconnected.

Interest in insect population decline has intensified following a startling 2017 study, which revealed that global insect populations had plummeted by 75% over the preceding three decades. This revelation has prompted numerous studies as scientists explore various hypotheses surrounding the causes of this ecological crisis.

To gain a better understanding of the academic landscape, the Binghamton University research team scrutinized over 175 scientific reviews, distilling more than 500 hypotheses related to insect decline. They constructed a vast interconnected network containing around 3,000 potential links, addressing a spectrum of influences extending from urban development to pest management practices.

“It’s quite challenging to gather diverse opinions in one place. Instead, we opted to review existing literature, focusing on meta-analyses and reviews,” explained Christopher Halsch, the lead author and post-doctoral researcher at Binghamton. “Our goal was to extract identified ‘causal pathways,’ such as how agriculture can lead to pollution, ultimately resulting in declines in insect populations. We then mapped these pathways to reveal connections between various stressors and their root causes.”

Among the myriad links identified, agricultural intensification emerged as the most frequently mentioned factor contributing to insect decline, influenced by practices such as land transformation and pesticide application.

However, the dynamics are intricate, as various systems influence one another. While climate is recognized as a contributor to insect decline, it encompasses specific factors like extreme weather events, elevated temperatures, and wildfires, each of which can have cascading effects on other drivers. This interconnected web of influences creates a synergistic landscape of threats.

Moreover, the researchers highlighted areas that remain largely unaddressed in the current literature. Notably, the International Union for the Conservation of Nature has compiled a comprehensive list of potential threats to insects, but many of these issues are often neglected in recent studies on insect decline.

“Natural disasters, for instance, were absent from the discussions,” noted Eliza Grames, an Assistant Professor of Biological Sciences involved in a study that showed a striking 20% decline in U.S. butterfly populations. “Furthermore, topics such as human encroachments, warfare, and impacts from infrastructure like railroads are rarely examined. While we acknowledge these as threats to biodiversity, current insect decline literature tends to focus predominantly on a narrow set of major stressors.”

The research team also observed significant biases in the literature, particularly towards “popular” insects such as bees and butterflies. This disproportionate attention may hinder conservation efforts for the vast array of other insect species.

“The focus on pollinators like bees has constrained our ability to implement conservation strategies that benefit other insect groups,” Grames explained.

“Bees command agricultural importance and public interest, attracting considerable research funding and focus,” Halsch added. “This creates a feedback loop: the more we prioritize research on bees, the more knowledge we gain about them, which comes at the expense of understanding other species.”

The researchers underscored the necessity for comprehensive conservation efforts that consider all drivers of insect decline holistically rather than in isolation.

“One critical point we wish to stress is that an emphasis on specific insects or stressors in conservation strategies may inadvertently harm many others,” Halsch cautioned. “If we concentrate excessively on bees and butterflies, we risk neglecting a vast number of other species, a majority of which are in dire need of attention.”

Source
www.sciencedaily.com