Photo credit: www.goldderby.com
As the 2025 Oscar season reaches its conclusion, several voters from the Academy Awards have opened up about their selections to Gold Derby, sharing their insights on the films and performances that captured their attention. We have assured them confidentiality regarding their identities while presenting their thoughts transparently. Now that the voting has wrapped up, we can divulge some anonymous ballots, including those of Voter 5. Additional summaries from Oscar Voter 1 through 4 can also be found below.
BEST PICTURE: Conclave
The support for films that resonate with voters is crucial, regardless of the final outcome. One voter expressed strong backing for Conclave, viewing it as an underdog in the race. They acknowledged that the creative team behind the film deserved recognition, regardless of external accolades like the Golden Globes or critics’ picks from major cities. For this voter, Conclave stands out as a film that merits respect, with other contenders including Emilia Pérez in second place and A Complete Unknown taking third.
BEST DIRECTOR: Jacques Audiard (Emilia Pérez)
The competition for this award is particularly fierce, with one voter leaning towards Jacques Audiard for his directorial work in Emilia Pérez. This choice reflects a deep appreciation for Audiard’s ability to balance a complex narrative and evoke empathy for the lead character, despite the story’s harsh realities and the presence of a brutal cartel figure.
BEST ACTRESS: Karla Sofía Gascón (Emilia Pérez)
This year’s performance by Karla Sofía Gascón has been noted for its depth and intensity, shifting from the lighter tone of the previous film. One voter highlighted Gascón’s standout performance, suggesting it be remembered alongside other strong contenders like Fernanda Torres, whose work was also commendable. Gascón’s phenomenal showing, they emphasized, should not be overshadowed by surrounding controversies, as the film itself is deserving of attention.
BEST ACTOR: Ralph Fiennes (Conclave)
While there seems to be momentum building for Adrien Brody, one voter personally advocates for Ralph Fiennes for his compelling role in Conclave. The voter argues that the film, despite facing tough competition, is worthy of recognition and that efforts are being made to keep it at the forefront of public consciousness, especially through streaming platforms.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS: Zoe Saldaña (Emilia Pérez)
One voter’s choice for Best Supporting Actress goes to Zoe Saldaña, who they feel delivered a truly remarkable performance. The voter expressed concern that the surrounding buzz might detract from her accomplishments. They noted that while awards tend to highlight the film overall, Saldaña’s individual talent must not be overlooked, as she commands attention whenever she is on screen.
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR: Jeremy Strong (The Apprentice)
For Best Supporting Actor, the voter expressed a strong preference for Jeremy Strong, appreciating his portrayal that encapsulated the character’s intricate background. The voter speculated that Strong’s campaign might not have received adequate funding, potentially limiting his exposure to a wider audience, and suggested that more efforts in marketing would have been beneficial.
BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY: Conclave
The voter sees Conclave as a testament to classic storytelling, deserving recognition for its narrative craft, despite it not being the most prominent title in discussions.
BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY: A Real Pain
When it comes to Original Screenplay, this voter is rooting for A Real Pain, favoring it over September 5. They expressed a sense of loss at the film’s conclusion, praising its captivating storyline and outstanding performances throughout.
SIGN UP for Gold Derby’s free newsletter with latest predictions
Source
www.goldderby.com