Photo credit: movieweb.com

Jack Quaid Shines in ‘Neighborhood Watch’, a Unique Crime Thriller

The last few years have witnessed a remarkable upward trajectory for actor Jack Quaid, particularly in 2025, where he has consistently taken on new roles since skyrocketing to fame with Prime Video’s The Boys in 2019. In April, he stars in Neighborhood Watch, a crime thriller directed by Duncan Skiles that channels the spirit of 1980s film-making.

Neighborhood Watch might not garner the same accolades as some of Quaid’s earlier projects, yet it represents a significant step in his career development. While he proved his capability to front a studio film with the high-energy Novocaine and dabbled in darker themes with Companion, it’s his nuanced portrayal in Neighborhood Watch that allows him to showcase his acting versatility in a subtly layered role.

In the film, Quaid plays Simon, a character grappling with schizophrenia who believes he has witnessed a kidnapping. His performance is marked by a compelling mix of anxiety and determination, brought to life through expressive eyes and a careful restraint that avoids the traps of melodrama. Paired with Jeffrey Dean Morgan, who portrays Ed, a down-on-his-luck former campus security guard, the duo navigates a narrative filled with tension and dark humor while echoing the dynamics of classic odd-couple films from the Reagan era, such as Martin Brest’s Midnight Run.

Jack Quaid Takes a One-Note Character and Makes Us Care About Him

The film, rated 2.5 out of 5, may be perceived as lower-tier compared to Quaid’s other works this year, but it stands out in its emotional resonance. Quaid effectively breathes complexity into Simon, a character initially characterized by singular traits associated with his mental health challenges. Though Simon has his struggles, including a background marked by self-harm and hallucinations involving his late father, he is not easily defined by his condition. His journey begins with a chaotic job interview showcasing his volatility and continues through his fraught interactions in a dilapidated Birmingham neighborhood.

The visual depiction of Simon’s world, with its derelict storefronts and faded walls, captures the atmosphere of isolation that mirrors his internal state, thanks to cinematographer Luke McCoubrey’s work. When Simon perceives a young woman abduction, his version of events is met with skepticism from local authorities, adding to his feeling of isolation. His decision to approach Ed reflects his desperation for validation amid his paranoia.

Simon may be the face of the film, but Ed ultimately presents a more intricate character. Portrayed as a disgruntled individual coping with job loss and financial instability, Ed is steeped in his own malaise, further complicated by his dubious attempts at a law enforcement façade. Initially dismissive of Simon’s claims, Ed finds himself reluctantly drawn into the investigation, which in some ways serves as a means to reclaim a sense of purpose in his monotonous life.

‘Neighborhood Watch’ is no ‘Zodiac’… And That’s Okay

The investigative plot of Neighborhood Watch lacks the depth of films like David Fincher’s Zodiac, yet that’s not its aim. Instead, it explores an unlikely partnership built on necessity and the search for self-worth. Simon’s emotional struggles and Ed’s reluctant mentorship slowly dissolve the barriers between them, giving rise to a friendship that carries significant weight despite the storyline’s simplicity.

The film’s challenges are reflected in Simon’s unpredictable outbursts, particularly during visits to the DMV and an auto junkyard that highlight his turbulent state. These moments of levity and tension drive forward the idea of companionship in hardship, a recurring theme that finds resolution as Ed provides Simon with tools to manage his mental health.

‘Neighborhood Watch’ Is Content to Be Moderately Engaging

Neighborhood Watch serves its purpose as a character-driven narrative while not reaching for a deeper exploration of its themes. Simon’s illness, treated with respect, avoids being a source of ridicule. However, instances where his challenges become mere plot devices detract from the thoughtful rendering of his character. The film does introduce minor backstory elements through Simon’s interactions with a supportive sister, played by Malin Akerman, adding a much-needed layer to his character development.

Although Skiles attempts to elevate the narrative as the plot unfolds, the film’s conclusion reveals an issue that may exceed its modest capacity. Perhaps the film’s strength lies in its ability to maintain a light-hearted yet gritty atmosphere, which resonates effectively throughout. Despite its occasional dips in momentum, Neighborhood Watch will likely be remembered as a solid entry in Quaid’s rising career. The film is set to be released in theaters and on VOD on April 25, 2025, produced by Redwire Pictures and Filmopoly Production and distributed by RLJE Films.

Source
movieweb.com