Photo credit: www.bbc.com

Controversy Arises Over VAR Decision in Atletico vs. Real Madrid Match

In a recent match between Atletico Madrid and Real Madrid, a controversial VAR decision has sparked differing views from both coaches regarding its legitimacy. Atletico’s coach, Diego Simeone, expressed skepticism about the ruling after his team was denied a penalty.

Simeone recounted the referee’s explanation, stating, “The referee said that when Julian got to the penalty spot, he touched the ball with his standing foot, but the ball did not move.” This moment raised questions for Simeone, who noted, “I’ve never seen a penalty awarded where VAR was called into play, but I want to believe that the officials saw what they needed to.” He further challenged those present at the stadium, asking if anyone had witnessed the ball moving, indicating that doubt lingered over the decision.

On the other hand, Real Madrid’s coach, Carlo Ancelotti, defended the VAR process, agreeing that the right call was reached. “They detected it,” he remarked, clarifying that the officials were already alerted to the potential infraction via VAR. “I saw it; I think he touches it with his left foot, a second touch.” Ancelotti’s confidence in the decision contrasts sharply with Simeone’s doubts.

Real Madrid’s goalkeeper, Thibaut Courtois, acknowledged the unfortunate situation for Atletico but reiterated that the rules dictated a correct disallowance of the attempt. He explained, “We sensed something was wrong and informed the referee, who then confirmed a double touch.” Courtois described the moment as unfortunate for Atletico, stating, “It’s bad luck, but it’s the rules.” He pointed out that the player involved, Julian Alvarez, had slipped, resulting in the ball being touched twice, which is a violation of penalty kick regulations.

Adding to the discussion, former Newcastle and Republic of Ireland goalkeeper Shay Given shared insights on BBC Match of the Day. He noted that similar situations can occur when the ball is inadvertently kicked by an alternate foot, redirecting its path. “In this case, the ball doesn’t change direction significantly, but [Alvarez] does kick the ball off his right foot. The laws of the game are explicit,” he stated.

This incident underscores the ongoing debates surrounding the use of VAR and its impact on the game, highlighting the fine line between judgment and regulations in modern football.

Source
www.bbc.com