Photo credit: www.cnbc.com
Jalen Brunson, #11 of the New York Knicks, demonstrates his skills on the court during the game against the Indiana Pacers in Round 2, Game 1 of the 2024 NBA Playoffs at Madison Square Garden in New York City on May 6, 2024.
As the New York Knicks experience a noteworthy season under the leadership of James Dolan, their parent company, the financial situation for their associated television networks paints a different picture. MSG Networks, which is a subsidiary of Sphere Entertainment, finds itself grappling with significant financial challenges, particularly as it engages in talks with lenders to refinance a staggering $829 million in debt, as indicated in recent public records. Compounding these issues, the network’s availability has been disrupted for viewers on Altice USA since January 1 due to an ongoing carriage dispute. A spokesperson for Altice noted that around one million Optimum cable subscribers previously had access to MSG Networks as part of their subscription.
This predicament faced by MSG Networks becomes particularly concerning for Knicks fans, especially during a season that has brought renewed hope and excitement.
MSG Networks not only broadcasts Knicks games but also covers local games for several NHL teams, including the New York Rangers, New York Islanders, Buffalo Sabres, and New Jersey Devils. Despite the Knicks’ historical ups and downs, they remain a beloved franchise, currently positioned for a competitive playoff run.
Under Coach Tom Thibodeau, the Knicks are entering the NBA All-Star weekend with momentum from consecutive wins. Standout players Jalen Brunson and Karl-Anthony Towns have been named All-Star starters, marking the first time since 2016 that a Knicks player has earned this honor, previously held by Carmelo Anthony.
However, the financial instability of MSG Networks poses risks for the loyal fan base that supports the Knicks.
“MSG Networks plays a crucial role in foster engagement with our local fans,” stated Jamaal Lesane, chief operating officer of Madison Square Garden Sports Corp., during a February earnings call. He acknowledged the potential long-term implications of the ongoing blackout, noting, “If this situation persists, we risk a shrinking fan base.” Sports media consultant Lee Berke echoed these sentiments, stressing that a shift to a more limited cable viewership could hinder the team’s future appeal to younger audiences.
Challenges in the Cable Sports Landscape
James L. Dolan, the Executive Chairman and CEO of the Madison Square Garden Company, has faced scrutiny from fans, particularly in light of recent events impacting MSG Networks. The current blackout underscores the precarious nature of the network’s financial arrangements, as debt repayment discussions unfold amid extended deadlines from lenders.
The blackout amid the Knicks’ strong performance has raised further questions. Discussions regarding stakeholder contracts have emerged, with MSG Networks seeking to renegotiate agreements in light of its financial constraints, including potential reductions in media rights fees.
Similar circumstances arose during the bankruptcy proceedings of Diamond Sports earlier this year, which resulted in streamlined agreements and altered fee structures due to financial pressures.
Historically high fees from regional sports networks have bolstered the financial standing of the teams and leagues involved. The Knicks derive substantial revenue not just from media rights but also from ticket sales, concessions, and merchandise, further enhancing their financial portfolio.
The long-term deal signed between MSG Networks and the Knicks in 2015 guarantees significant compensation for local broadcasts, contributing meaningfully to MSG’s overall revenue. Projections indicate MSG Networks paid approximately $175.3 million to MSG Sports in fiscal 2024, a figure expected to climb to about $187 million in 2025, a testament to the value of these television rights.
Financial analysts estimate that the Knicks benefit the most from these rights fees, with local media rights revenues nearing $149 million, just slightly behind the Los Angeles Lakers. Other notable teams, like the Houston Rockets and Philadelphia 76ers, currently receive around $60 million annually.
The impending NBA media rights deals, set to commence in the 2025-26 season, may provide some relief to MSG Sports if the blackout with Altice persists. Increased national broadcasts will open more avenues for fans to view games, even as Dolan has expressed concerns regarding the deal’s impact on regional networks.
Despite the expected boost in national rights revenues, analysts suggest that any gains could be offset by losses incurred from the MSG Networks’ ongoing complications.
Fan Impact and Regional Sports Network Issues
The turmoil impacting MSG Networks is reflective of broader trends facing regional sports networks across the country, yet the intertwining of the Knicks as part of a publicly traded entity complicates the narrative, illuminating the financial vulnerabilities of both entities.
The blackout that began on January 1 came at a fortuitous time for the Knicks, who enjoyed an eight-game winning streak at the height of the dispute. The crux of the issue lies in negotiations over fees, as Altice and other distributors seek to recalibrate the traditional model of regional sports broadcasting in light of declining cable subscriptions.
With about a third of MSG Networks’ distribution reliant on Altice subscribers, this blackout represents a significant financial hit. New York politicians have raised their voices against the standoff, urging both parties to restore access to the sought-after broadcasts. Governor Kathy Hochul articulated these sentiments in a recent letter, emphasizing the importance of access to sports content for fans.
Despite ongoing appeals, progress in negotiations remains stalled, with MSG Networks demanding that Altice refund customers who remain on plans that included MSG programming. At the same time, Altice has encouraged customers to explore alternative viewing options, including internet TV bundles that feature MSG Networks.
In response to the evolving landscape, MSG Networks has ventured into streaming services, collaborating with other networks and offering monthly subscriptions, aiming to provide access to die-hard fans, although this may deter more casual viewers.
As the sports media landscape continues to transform, the future of MSG Networks—and by extension, the New York Knicks’ accessibility to their fans—remains uncertain amidst a backdrop of shifting viewer preferences and financial pressures.
Source
www.cnbc.com