Photo credit: www.foodandwine.com

Red vs. White Wine: Reevaluating Health Benefits and Cancer Risks

Red wine has long been celebrated as the “healthier” choice, primarily because of its rich content of antioxidants, particularly polyphenols. These compounds, especially resveratrol, are often touted for their potential to combat inflammation and even possess anti-cancer properties. Nonetheless, recent findings from a study conducted by researchers at Brown University are challenging these widely held beliefs regarding the health benefits of red wine compared to white wine.

According to Eunyoung Cho, an associate professor of epidemiology and dermatology at Brown and co-lead author of the study, “We conducted a comprehensive meta-analysis to assess whether red wine is truly a healthier choice than white wine.” The research encompassed a significant amount of epidemiological data, evaluating the relationships between red and white wine consumption and cancer risk across numerous studies.

This extensive analysis incorporated data from 42 observational studies with nearly 96,000 participants. The results revealed a risk ratio of 0.98 for red wine drinkers, contrasting with a risk ratio of 1.00 for those who preferred white wine. This indicates that neither type of wine had a statistically significant impact on the overall rates of cancer. The researchers pointed out that the purported benefits of resveratrol may be minimal, primarily because its effectiveness could be diminished by rapid metabolism in the body. Ultimately, the findings suggested “no significant difference in cancer risk between red and white wine overall.”

However, Cho highlighted an intriguing distinction throughout the study: “The consumption of white wine, but not red wine, was associated with an increased risk of skin cancer.” Further examination of cohort studies, which are generally more reliable than case-control studies, uncovered that those who consumed white wine displayed a slightly elevated cancer risk, reflected in a risk ratio of 1.12. The analysis of six specific studies indicated that individuals who drank white wine had a 22% increased likelihood of developing skin cancer compared to their red wine-consuming counterparts, though the underlying reasons for this association remain uncertain.

One possible explanation, as Cho mentions, is that higher alcohol consumption could correlate with risky behaviors such as excessive sun exposure, inadequate sunscreen application, or indoor tanning. Nonetheless, the study could not clarify why white wine appeared to be the more significant factor in skin cancer risk.

Another theory considers the potential for white wine to generate elevated levels of acetaldehyde, a known carcinogen produced during alcohol metabolism. While the current study did not directly compare acetaldehyde levels between the two types of wine, previous research published in the journal “Food Science and Biotechnology” suggests that white wine may contain higher concentrations of this compound due to the difference in fermentation processes associated with each type of wine. However, Cho urged caution in drawing definitive conclusions, emphasizing that “more research is needed to better understand the potential mechanisms behind this.”

The study also revealed a pronounced link between white wine consumption and a heightened overall cancer risk, particularly among women. The researchers expressed that this meta-analysis is pioneering in its approach and challenges the conventional wisdom that red wine is inherently healthier than white wine. It further underscores the necessity for additional investigation into the correlation between white wine and cancer risk, especially in female populations.

In light of these findings, Cho articulated a crucial takeaway: “there are no safe alcoholic beverages in terms of cancer prevention.” When reflecting on whether this study has altered her own drinking habits, she stated, “Not really, as I don’t drink often. Not drinking alcoholic beverages is one of the best practices for cancer prevention.”

Source
www.foodandwine.com