Photo credit: www.technologyreview.com
Challenges and Opportunities of Offshore Space Launches
In recent discussions surrounding the regulation of offshore space launches, Alla Pozdnakova, a law professor at the University of Oslo’s Scandinavian Institute for Maritime Law, expressed concerns about the inconsistencies in nationality and ownership transparency among various states. “Some countries impose stringent regulations, whereas others have more lenient requirements,” she noted. In the United States, for example, citizens and companies must obtain a license from the relevant space authorities regardless of the launch location.
The variability in international regulatory frameworks may create opportunities for less oversight in sea-based launches. Pozdnakova highlighted a potential for unauthorized projects to emerge due to the relative lack of authority governing maritime activities, unlike the more structured regulations applicable to land-based launches.
Historic precedents illustrate the legal and environmental complexities tied to offshore launches. Boeing, which previously operated the Sea Launch program, was penalized with a $10 million fine in 1998 by the U.S. Department of State for allegedly violating the Arms Export Control Act by sharing sensitive defense technologies. Furthermore, concerns were raised by Pacific Island nations at the United Nations in 1999 about the environmental risks posed by Sea Launch, particularly regarding potential oil spills from unused fuel in discarded rocket boosters.
The implications of offshore spaceports on international law, environmental sustainability, and launch accessibility are becoming increasingly pertinent. SpaceX, noted for its innovation in rocket recovery, has shown interest in maritime launch capabilities. In 2020, the company acquired two oil rigs for $3.5 million each, renaming them Deimos and Phobos, after the moons of Mars.
“SpaceX is building floating, superheavy-class spaceports for Mars, moon & hypersonic travel around Earth,” declared CEO Elon Musk in a 2020 tweet. However, this venture was eventually set aside, and the rigs were sold. Despite this, Gwynne Shotwell, SpaceX’s president and COO, suggested in 2023 that sea-based launches might still be a part of their long-term strategy, although the company did not provide further comment on the issue.
As SpaceX continues to pursue its ambitious Starship program—envisioned as the most powerful rocket ever built—there may be a need to explore offshore launch capabilities. According to Shotwell, the design of Starship aims to mirror aircraft operations closely. “We want to talk about dozens of launches a day, if not hundreds of launches a day,” she stated at a conference in 2023.
The environmental consequences of conducting hundreds of daily launches, whether from land or sea, remain largely uncertain. While offshore launches may reduce immediate environmental risks compared to terrestrial sites, the broader implications of rocket emissions and potential chemical pollutants are still inadequately understood, particularly at significantly escalated launch frequencies.
Source
www.technologyreview.com