Photo credit: www.cnbc.com

Challenges in Active Management: Insights from Industry Experts

Stock picking may seem straightforward, but data reveals a stark reality. According to S&P Global, a significant 73% of active managers fail to outperform their benchmarks within the first year. This trend deteriorates over time, with an alarming 95.5% underperforming after five years, and after a span of 15 years, a complete lack of outperformance becomes evident.

The Burgeoning Passive Investment Trend

Charles Ellis, a prominent figure in the investment world and an advocate for indexing, foresees this trend persisting. He argues that while the growth in passive funds raises concerns about the future of active management, it does not diminish the passion and competitiveness that fuel the active management sector. “The number of people that get hired into active management keeps rising, and we’re way overloaded with talent in that area,” he noted during a recent appearance on CNBC’s “ETF Edge”.

Recent Performance of Active ETFs

Echoing Ellis’s sentiments, ETF industry expert Dave Nadig remarked that active managers remain a significant presence. He highlighted that the past year marked a record high for active management inflows. “It isn’t that anybody thinks active management shouldn’t exist, but the vast majority of flows are coming from fairly unsophisticated individual investors going into big indexes and big target data funds,” he added, drawing attention to the dominating trend of investor preference for index funds.

Concerns Over ETF Growth

Ellis, who previously founded Greenwich Associates and served on the board of The Vanguard Group, expressed his concerns regarding the expanding ETF landscape. He acknowledged the positive aspects, such as an increase in available ETFs and a consistent decline in management fees. However, he warned of potential pitfalls, particularly regarding new ETFs that may cater more to the interests of salespeople than actual buyers. “You must worry about the ETFs that are being produced much more for the salesperson than the buyer and how they’re too specialized and too narrow,” he explained. His apprehensions extend to leveraged ETFs, which he believes can lead to unpredictable outcomes.

Investing with Purpose

For investors navigating the ETF market, Ellis emphasizes the importance of aligning investment choices with personal goals. He urged investors to ensure they select ETFs that best match their intended objectives.

The Role of Technology in Investment Strategies

Nadig pointed out that the advancement of technology has leveled the playing field for market participants. With similar resources at their disposal, gaining a competitive edge becomes increasingly challenging. “Active management is possible; you’ll just never find it in advance,” he stated.

The Paradox of Active Management

Interestingly, Ellis noted that one of the reasons active managers struggle is their collective proficiency. “The ironic reason that active managers underperform is that they’re all so good at what they’re trying to do; they cancel each other out,” he remarked. In today’s environment, where sophisticated computing power and quantitative models are widely accessible, the landscape resembles “playing poker with all the cards face up,” he added, underscoring the complexities of achieving consistent outperformance.

Disclaimer

Source
www.cnbc.com