The Informant Who Unveiled the Hidden Secrets of the Black Chamber: One of America’s Early Code-Breaking Agencies

Photo credit: www.smithsonianmag.com

In the shadows of New York City’s speakeasies during the late 1920s, cryptologist Herbert O. Yardley found himself embroiled in a dangerous game of espionage. One fateful night in 1929, a captivating woman engaged him in conversation, though Yardley sensed something unsettling beneath her charm. As he nursed his whiskey, he later reflected on the curious nature of her interest in a man of his appearance, which made him wary. When she briefly excused herself to the restroom, Yardley seized the opportunity to search her purse, uncovering only a few mundane items and a typewritten note indicating urgency to obtain intelligence. His instincts proved correct, enabling him to escape another potential espionage trap, yet it also marked the beginning of the end for his tenure as head of the covert Black Chamber.

Established in 1919, the Black Chamber was an early American intelligence organization that operated away from public scrutiny, focusing on codes and ciphers for both domestic and international communications. Yardley, discontented with the agency’s dwindling influence, bared its secrets in a candid memoir published in 1931, The American Black Chamber. This revelation preceded the seismic intelligence scandal instigated by Edward Snowden by more than eight decades.

Yardley, born on April 13, 1889, in Indiana, demonstrated mathematical prowess early on. He began his career as a code clerk with the State Department, where his talent for decrypting complex messages became evident when he broke a significant code involving President Woodrow Wilson. Concerned by the ease of his accomplishment, he prepared a memo detailing the vulnerabilities of American diplomatic codes. As America entered World War I, his skills led him to the Army, where he was crucial in establishing the MI-8, a cryptology unit that rapidly expanded and proved vital to the war effort.

MI-8 garnered renown for its ability to decipher enemy communications, playing a pivotal role in apprehending spies like Pablo Waberski and Maria de Victorica, navigating the challenges of intelligence work in a rapidly shifting European landscape. Following the war, Yardley sought to institutionalize MI-8’s successes, advocating for its continuation in peacetime, which led to the establishment of the Cipher Bureau, or Black Chamber. This organization would go on to decrypt vast quantities of foreign communications, often employing questionable methods.

The Black Chamber reached its zenith during the Washington Naval Conference, where intelligence gathered from decrypted Japanese codes allowed U.S. negotiators to gain a strategic advantage. However, as the 1920s progressed, and with changing political tides, the Chamber faced increased scrutiny. Yardley felt the pressure intensifying, especially under Secretary of State Henry L. Stimson, who famously declared, “Gentlemen do not read each other’s mail.” This was an ominous sign for the fate of the agency.

Officially disbanded in October 1929, the Black Chamber’s closure coincided with the onset of the Great Depression, leaving Yardley without employment or official recognition of his past contributions. In a desperate bid to support his family, he scandalously sold sensitive information regarding U.S. cryptographic capabilities to the Japanese government. This transaction, though lucrative, later became a significant chapter in his controversial life.

Yardley’s subsequent book The American Black Chamber became a bestseller, embarrassing an entire nation and provoking backlash from the U.S. government. While Yardley leveraged his notoriety to write more books and share his experiences, he soon found himself constrained by new legal frameworks aimed at safeguarding government secrets, such as the 1933 Secrets Act, which established serious penalties for unauthorized disclosures of classified information.

In the years to follow, Yardley attempted to reclaim his place within the literary and intelligence community but faced increasing obstacles, both from government scrutiny and fading opportunities. He briefly stepped into a new career in public housing and attempted to republish his earlier works, but the government’s watchful eye stifled many of his efforts. He became a technical advisor in Hollywood before ultimately fading from the spotlight, continuing to grapple with his controversial legacy until his death on August 7, 1958.

Yardley’s narrative reflects the complexities of espionage and the often tumultuous relationship between secrecy, government, and individual ambition. His life serves as a compelling study of the ethical dilemmas faced by those who operate at the intersections of public service and clandestine operations, leaving a lasting mark on America’s history of intelligence and cryptography.

Source
www.smithsonianmag.com