Photo credit: www.sciencenews.org

The Debate Over America’s Oldest Rock: A Geological Puzzle

In Minnesota’s River Valley, a weathered sign proudly declares the presence of the “World’s Oldest Rock.” This landmark, established in 1975, refers to the Morton Gneiss, which was believed to be 3.8 billion years old. However, recent research has challenged this long-held belief.

According to a study published in the March-April issue of GSA Today by geologist Carol Frost and her team, the title of the world’s oldest rock actually belongs to the Acasta Gneiss in Canada, estimated to be around 4 billion years old. Furthermore, the Morton Gneiss may not even be the oldest rock in the United States, as its age could be overestimated by at least 300 million years. The researchers suggest that the sign in Minnesota should be amended to read “America’s Oldest Rock,” and the title shifted to Michigan’s Watersmeet Gneiss, with an estimated age of at least 3.6 billion years.

This lively debate about rock dating underscores a crucial issue in geology: the challenge of accurately determining the ages of rocks and their constitutive minerals, which can affect our understanding of significant geological events. Bob Stern, a co-author of the study from the University of Texas at Dallas, humorously describes their inquiry as starting from what he calls “a beer question” that sparked a more in-depth investigation into the dating of ancient rocks.

Geologists date rocks primarily by analyzing the minerals within them. Frost explains that different minerals can have distinct formation ages, likening dating a rock to trying to determine the age of a building by assessing its bricks. This complexity raises fundamental philosophical queries about the true nature of a rock’s age. The durability of zircon, a mineral favored by geologists, complicates matters further. Zircon can endure severe weathering and geological processes, which may distort the information it provides about when it formed.

The team undertook comprehensive analyses of gneisses from key geological areas in Minnesota, Wyoming, and Michigan. Each rock, marked by unique striations and varied textures, carries its own history. Jeffrey Vervoort, a geologist from Washington State University, comments on the complexity of these samples, noting that they all show signs of geological turmoil.

To determine the ages of the gneisses, researchers use advanced techniques that involve firing lasers and ion beams at zircons to measure the decay of uranium to lead, a reliable method for dating rocks. The Morton Gneiss, while once thought to be 3.8 billion years old, contains zircon ages that range from 2.6 billion to 3.5 billion years old, indicating the likelihood of multiple rock formations being mixed together over time. In contrast, the Watersmeet Gneiss has a more conclusive minimum age of 3.6 billion years, which solidifies its claim to the title of “America’s Oldest Rock” — at least for now.

This exploration of America’s oldest rock is not merely academic; it has significant implications for understanding Earth’s history. Accurate dating is vital for establishing timelines concerning the emergence of life, the formation of mountains, and climatic shifts through the ages. Vervoort reassures that while this study may not drastically alter established geologic history, it emphasizes the inherent difficulty of dating early Earth rocks.

Mark Harrison of UCLA points to the limitations of the research, noting that the findings reflect only those rocks accessible at the surface. He advises that while the team has recorded the oldest known rock in the U.S., the quest for older rocks remains open, with many potentially buried deep within the Earth’s crust.

As discussions continue regarding the sign in Minnesota, geologists like Frost express hope for future discoveries. The dialogue surrounding the age and classification of these ancient gneisses illustrates the ongoing challenges in the field of geology, pointing to a critical need for careful research and open-minded exploration in the realm of Earth’s history.

Source
www.sciencenews.org