Photo credit: www.tvfanatic.com

Critique of John Nolan’s Character Arc in The Rookie

While John Nolan, portrayed by Nathan Fillion, has his supporters within the fanbase of *The Rookie*, there are growing concerns regarding the narrative choices surrounding his character. It seems that as the series progresses into its seventh season, the depiction of Nolan’s actions and the resulting consequences have become increasingly problematic.

The core issue lies in Nolan’s consistent ability to escape significant repercussions for his often reckless behavior, contrasting sharply with the experiences of other characters who face real consequences for similar actions. This disconnect becomes particularly noticeable in current storylines, where the stakes appear much higher for other characters while Nolan seems to navigate through his challenges relatively unscathed.

Comparative Consequences in Season 7

An illustrative moment occurred in Season 7, Episode 3, where two rookie officers, Seth and Miles, found themselves in a precarious situation. Despite defying orders and plunging into a hostage scenario, viewers anticipated repercussions, knowing their reckless choices endangered lives. Their actions were emblematic of inexperienced officers learning the ropes, and the audience expects that learning curve to come with enforced discipline.

Conversely, Nolan’s behavior during the same narrative Arc underscores a different standard. In his pursuit to protect Bailey and tackle the threat posed by Jason, Nolan abandoned protocol, going off-book without backup. His solo mission culminated in further chaos, including leaving a gunshot victim unattended—a stark dereliction of duty that ordinarily would warrant significant scrutiny.

Fostering a Narrative of Impunity

This apparent shield around Nolan raises questions about the overarching narrative approach of the series. While his past as a rookie may have granted him some narrative leniency, the expectation of character growth and accountability becomes diminished as the story progresses. The series’ handling of Nolan suggests a troubling trend: plot armor that not only shields him from accountability but also stunts the potential for rich conflict that character-driven narratives thrive on.

In stark contrast, other characters like Bradford have faced tangible repercussions for their actions. After making questionable choices that impacted his colleagues, Bradford experienced demotion and struggled to restore his credibility within the department. This illustrates a clear lack of balance in the storytelling, as Nolan operates without facing similar scrutiny, despite involving others in his reckless schemes without providing necessary context or support.

The Ripple Effect on Supporting Characters

The uneven treatment of Nolan and his peers ultimately affects the dynamics within the show. Characters like Lucy find themselves facing repercussions for circumstances beyond their control, while Nolan wanders through his journey largely unaffected. This disparity raises serious questions about fairness within the narrative construct of *The Rookie*.

Interestingly, the interplay in Nolan’s marriage to Bailey further complicates the narrative landscape. Bailey’s character often seems to amplify Nolan’s issues rather than challenge or mitigate them. Their interactions, meant to provide levity, paradoxically underscore the character’s lack of growth and the show’s tendency to favor humor over genuine conflict resolution.

In conclusion, the portrayal of John Nolan as a character who risks little while continually putting others in harm’s way represents a broader narrative issue within *The Rookie*. For a show that has the potential to delve into the complexities of the police experience, the time has come for a reevaluation of how character arcs are developed. Nolan’s journey should reflect genuine growth through accountability and realistic conflict, aligning more closely with the challenges that his colleagues regularly face. *The Rookie* would undoubtedly benefit from addressing these discrepancies to maintain both narrative coherence and audience engagement.

Watch The Rookie Online

Source
www.tvfanatic.com