Photo credit: movieweb.com
When considering Christmas films, names like Tom Hardy and Guy Pearce may not immediately come to mind. Hardy is known for embracing complex characters that often lean towards more masculine portrayals, establishing himself as a highly skilled yet underestimated actor. In contrast, Pearce, while also talented, has not achieved the same level of recognition as Hardy, often gravitating towards similarly assertive roles. While the holiday season typically highlights themes of joy and togetherness, it seems an unusual pairing for such manly actors.
This raises the question: why did their collaboration on A Christmas Carol not gain the attention it deserved? Is it merely one of many excellent adaptations that gets overshadowed by the annual influx of Christmas films? In this article, we will explore this somewhat overlooked adaptation, investigate the reasons for its lack of acclaim, and discuss why it deserves a place on your viewing list this holiday season—provided you’re open to a darker interpretation of the beloved classic.
Not Just Another Adaption of ‘A Christmas Carol’
Release Date: December 19, 2019
Seasons: 1
It is widely accepted that Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol is the premier Christmas narrative worldwide, with hundreds of adaptations across film and television. Many of these variations closely follow the original storyline and have become staples of holiday viewing, including the classics like A Christmas Carol (1938), Scrooge (1970), and The Muppet Christmas Carol (1992).
Debuting in 2019 as a miniseries on BBC One and FX, A Christmas Carol presented three episodes, each over 40 minutes long. While it retains the fundamental premise—Scrooge encountering spirits at Christmastime to gain new insights into his life—the series differentiates itself through a decidedly more mature lens and additional narrative twists.
This adaptation brings a notably darker tone compared to its predecessors, featuring graphic scenes, mature themes, and adult language. It delves deeper into complex issues, including Scrooge’s childhood trauma, specifically, his experience of sexual abuse, which informs his later treatment of women. The narrative also introduces a more pronounced political commentary, tweaks to character portrayals, and an alternative ending, all while remaining true to the core themes of Dickens’s work.
What Makes 2019’s ‘A Christmas Carol’ Great
The 2019 adaptation benefits from a stellar cast. Guy Pearce’s portrayal of Scrooge offers a reflective take on the character, while Andy Serkis delivers a haunting performance as the Ghost of Christmas Past, and Stephen Graham brings a fresh interpretation to Jacob Marley. With an ensemble that includes Joe Alwyn, Vinette Robinson, Lenny Rush, Jason Flemyng, and Charlotte Riley, the performances are commendable and contribute significantly to the series’ depth. Tom Hardy, serving as executive producer alongside other notable names like Ridley Scott, recognizes the potential of this project.
While the mature aspects certainly add intrigue, it’s the script crafted by Steven Knight that elevates this adaptation. It skillfully weaves emotional weight and thoughtful reflections into the well-worn narrative, inviting viewers to ponder its contemporary significance. Audience reactions have been favorable; while it lacks a formal critic score, it stands at 81% on the Popcornmeter, boasts a 7.3/10 rating on IMDb, and has garnered a 3.2/5 on Letterboxd.
Why ‘A Christmas Carol’ Remains Underrated
Despite its stellar cast and innovative interpretation aimed at adult viewers, the reason 2019’s A Christmas Carol struggles for recognition is clear. The series format does not easily lend itself to casual holiday watching; even when episodes are compiled, the extended runtime can be intimidating for those amid the festive rush. This can deter potential viewers who might otherwise enjoy a more traditional film experience.
Moreover, this iteration’s appeal is curtailed by its mature themes, which naturally limits its audience appeal during the holiday season. Ideal for viewing when the children have settled down, it may not fit the typical holiday mood where viewers often gravitate towards more sentimental fare. Nonetheless, for those ready to embrace its darker, more reflective tone, 2019’s A Christmas Carol provides a unique narrative experience that deviates from standard holiday offerings. You can catch 2019’s A Christmas Carol streaming on Hulu.
Source
movieweb.com