Photo credit: www.motorsport.com
NASCAR penalties can be challenging for teams to contest, though it is not entirely out of the question. Richard Childress Racing is currently appealing a disqualification from last weekend’s NASCAR Xfinity Series, seeking the reinstatement of Jesse Love’s victory at Rockingham. Earlier this season, Joe Gibbs Racing successfully appealed a ruling that lifted all penalties against Chase Briscoe, connected to issues discovered with his Daytona 500 pole-winning vehicle.
The appeal process in NASCAR is structured and well-defined. Teams and drivers must initiate an appeal within a specified timeframe—typically 24 hours for race disqualifications. For other penalties not directly affecting the championship, the appeal period can extend up to three business days. Once an appeal is filed, the process moves forward, scheduling a hearing date that must occur within a month, although expedited appeals can be arranged in urgent situations.
The Role of the NMPA
The National Motorsports Appeals Panel (NMPA) plays a crucial role in this process, tasked with hearing the cases presented by both sides. Comprised of three experienced volunteers, the NMPA offers an unbiased perspective on the matter. Each appeal features a different set of panel members who come from varied backgrounds, including former racers and individuals without racing experience, all selected by an Appeal Administrator.
During the appeal hearing, representatives from both NASCAR and the appealing party present their cases without legal counsel. Each side has the opportunity to submit evidence and respond to questions from the panel. The NMPA’s verdict is rendered post-hearing; they can choose to uphold, amend, or overturn the penalties, and their decision requires unanimity along with a detailed explanation for the ruling.
Burden of Proof and the Final Appeals Officer
A key aspect of the appeals process is the distribution of the burden of proof. While NASCAR bears this burden during the initial phase, it shifts to the appellant when the matter escalates to the Final Appeals Officer (FAO), who serves as the ultimate authority on the issue. This singular official’s ruling is final, leaving no room for further appeals. Richard Childress Racing previously reached the FAO level in the 2024 NASCAR Cup season when seeking to restore Austin Dillon’s playoff position, following a contentious victory at Richmond.
Source
www.motorsport.com