Photo credit: www.smithsonianmag.com

The Secrets Behind Mammalian Hearing: New Insights into Outer Ear Evolution

Many mammals are renowned for their exceptional auditory capabilities. Bats, for instance, utilize echolocation to pinpoint small insects in complete darkness, while elephants can discern the calls of companions from nearly a mile away. Rabbits benefit from their acute sense of hearing, alerting them to the presence of predators before they draw close.

Despite the physical diversity among these species, they share a critical anatomical characteristic: external ears.

Research into the evolutionary significance of outer ears, which are a hallmark of mammals, has gained momentum recently. Two studies published in early January have begun to shed light on the intricacies of these soft structures that are pivotal for auditory functions.

The first study, appearing in the journal Science, reveals the discovery of a novel type of cartilage, potentially crucial to understanding the enhanced hearing abilities of mammals.

This new cartilage, dubbed “lipocartilage,” was identified serendipitously during preparations to examine ear tissues from mice. Researchers observed that the ear tissue appeared distinctly different after chemical treatments, revealing cells packed with lipids—substances typically associated with fat rather than connective tissues. This unique combination offers insights into the structure and flexibility that may contribute to superior hearing.

Upon further investigation, the team uncovered lipocartilage in the external ears of various mammals, including humans, as well as in the noses, sternums, and larynxes of mice. Notably, this tissue was absent in birds, amphibians, and reptiles—groups lacking outer ears. This absence suggests that lipocartilage may play a significant role in the advanced auditory capabilities of mammals, as explained by Markéta Kaucká, a developmental biologist at the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Biology.

The second study, published in the journal Nature, takes the investigation further by illustrating potential genetic links between the development of mammalian outer ears and the gills of fish. This research builds on existing theories suggesting that the jaw bones of ancient fish evolved into the three ossicles found in the mammalian inner ear.

The findings provide crucial insights into the challenging study of outer ear evolution, as cartilage tends to deteriorate over time and presents difficulties for fossilization compared to bones.

“When we began this research, the origins of the outer ear were not well understood,” stated Gage Crump, a co-author of the Nature study. His assessment underscores the significance of their findings, showcasing parallels in gene expression patterns and sequences between zebrafish gill tissues and human ear cartilage.

The transformation from gill structures to outer ears did not occur linearly; rather, ancient vertebrates repurposed existing genetic frameworks responsible for gills. According to the research, the evolutionary potential embedded within these genetic programs allowed for the adaptation necessary for life on land.

Abigail Tucker, a developmental biologist at King’s College London, highlighted this remarkable aspect of evolution, remarking, “The regulatory networks that were originally designed for gill formation could be reconceptualized to create ear structures.”

Moreover, the same genetic mechanisms observed in the gills of horseshoe crabs—creatures with a lineage stretching back 400 million years—suggest that early fish utilized similar resources to initiate their own evolutionary journey toward more complex ear structures.

This emerging understanding of lipocartilage and its evolutionary roots illustrates how the flexible cartilage seen in modern mammals’ ears may well be an evolutionary echo of ancient invertebrate structures, as noted by Crump.

Source
www.smithsonianmag.com