Photo credit: phys.org

Valuing Caregiving: Insights into Americans’ Perceptions of Contribution

Research has revealed a notable disparity in how Americans perceive different forms of contribution to society, particularly in the context of volunteering versus caregiving. Despite the significant economic value of unpaid caregiving—estimated at over $450 billion annually—many Americans believe that volunteering to assist strangers is a more valuable societal contribution. This finding emerges from a study published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.

This viewpoint may create a sense of inadequacy among individuals from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, who may feel they lack the resources or time to contribute in ways that are recognized as impactful by broader societal standards. As noted by Ellen Reinhart, Ph.D., the lead author of the study from Michigan State University, “Over 53 million Americans provide unpaid care for adults, with their efforts accounting for a vast amount of labor that supports societal functions.”

In contrast, while Americans volunteer approximately 8.8 billion hours each year—valued at around $195 billion—debate persists on the comparative value of these contributions.

Study Overview

The research team conducted experiments to explore how individuals from varying socioeconomic statuses perceive their societal contributions. Participants were classified into two groups based on their education level: those with less than a four-year college degree were categorized as lower socioeconomic status, whereas those with a four-year degree or higher represented the higher socioeconomic status group. Generally, individuals in the lower socioeconomic group reported lower incomes and were more likely to work in manual or skilled labor positions.

Using data from the Midlife Development in the United States survey, collected across three waves from 1995 to 2014, researchers asked participants to reflect on their contributions through statements like, “I have something valuable to give the world” and “My daily activities do not create anything worthwhile for my community.” They were also prompted to disclose the number of hours spent volunteering or providing unpaid assistance to family and friends.

Interestly, the findings revealed that while higher socioeconomic individuals volunteered more often, those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds dedicated more time to unpaid caregiving within their social circles. Despite this greater involvement in caregiving, individuals from lower socioeconomic statuses reported feeling that their contributions paled in comparison to those who volunteered to help strangers.

Common Misconceptions

“This notion that helping strangers equates to a higher impact contribution appears to be a widely held but minimally examined belief,” Reinhart stated. “Our study sheds light on this assumption and prompts critical questions about its implications for different societal groups.”

In one component of the research, participants read profiles of individuals who tutored students in different contexts: one was mandated to tutor through an organization, one elected to tutor a stranger, and another helped a family member. The results indicated that participants uniformly regarded tutoring a stranger as a more significant contribution, regardless of their own socioeconomic status.

While tutors of family members were seen as more moral, this did not translate to a comparable value in perceived societal contribution. Instead, the choice involved in volunteering was viewed as the hallmark of altruism.

Broader Perspectives on Contribution

These observations suggest a need for society to broaden its understanding of what encompasses meaningful contributions. Reinhart emphasized that as demographic shifts occur—most notably, the aging U.S. population—the proportion of Americans engaged in caregiving for adults will likely rise, necessitating a reassessment of how this vital labor is understood and valued.

In conclusion, recognizing the personal and societal significance of local caregiving relationships is essential. Reinhart urged that “we must do more to highlight the vital role of informal caregivers and the profound impact of their contributions on both individuals and communities.”

More information: Who feels they contribute to U.S. society? Helping behaviors and social class disparities in perceived contributions, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, published online October 17, 2024. (PDF)

Citation: Volunteering to help strangers seen as greater contribution than caring for friends and family (2024, October 17) retrieved 17 October 2024 from https://phys.org/news/2024-10-volunteering-strangers-greater-contribution-friends.html

Source
phys.org