Photo credit: www.eater.com
At the conclusion of her new Netflix lifestyle series, With Love, Meghan, Meghan Sussex, previously known as Markle, enthusiastically declares, “Here we go; it’s a business!” This moment, set against the backdrop of a brunch with loved ones, makes it clear that the domestic charm she has cultivated over the series—including delightful recipes and homey activities like beekeeping—is all gearing up for her new brand, As Ever. In her closing remarks, Sussex reflects on the inspiration for her pursuit, connecting it to her earlier lifestyle blog, the Tig, and her desire to share her passions with those she cares about.
With Love, Meghan has already achieved success, as evidenced by Netflix’s swift renewal for a second season, which was filmed before the first season’s release. The platform has recognized her project as a “passive partner” in the As Ever venture. The show offers a blend of approachable cooking and entertaining advice, emphasizing the beauty of everyday moments and the effort to impress guests. Sussex showcases dishes like vibrant one-pot pastas and homemade candles, using materials readily available in local markets.
Her declaration, “it’s a business!” highlights the focus on commercialization within celebrity culture. Brands—be they fast food giants or kitchenware manufacturers—craft identities that can be marketed. For a celebrity, especially a woman leading a brand, there is the challenge of determining what aspects of her personal life and expertise she is ready to commercialize. This includes ongoing negotiations about her public image and personal narrative, raising questions about the extent of personal disclosure required in their brand strategy.
Navigating these waters can be particularly daunting for women, and even more so for someone like Sussex, who has faced extraordinary public scrutiny and racism. Public reactions to With Love often grapple with her fit within established domestic goddess roles, such as the nurturing Family Woman or the relatable Everywoman—a difficult balance for her to strike given her unique experiences that set her apart from typical influencers.
Sussex’s self-awareness comes through as she admits to being inexperienced in the culinary field, presenting a constant theme of humility in her show. This self-deprecation suggests a strategic choice to sidestep the scrutiny that would inevitably follow a misstep, highlighting the precarious position she occupies in the entertainment space. Some of her claims, like not knowing about brining chicken in milk, raise eyebrows yet align with her strategy of relatability often sought by female content creators, particularly women of color.
In this competitive environment, Sussex positions herself as a tastemaker among the upper and upper-middle classes, creating content that resonates with those social groups. However, critics note that her approach predominantly reflects the aesthetics typical of the wealthy, particularly in her limited portrayal of racial diversity within the show. The lack of broader Black representation raises concerns about her commitment to inclusivity, as she often draws predominantly from her own affluent social circle.
Both this show and her earlier documentary series demonstrate a trend of underrepresentation. In With Love, there is a significant absence of non-White voices, with only one Black friend making a sporadic appearance. This lack of inclusivity stands in stark contrast to her mission of celebrating communal joy and connection, leaving viewers wanting to see more diversity. The segments featuring non-White contributors often focus on their experiences with racism, yet here the absence negates those discussions, missing opportunities to bridge cultural divides.
The potential for a more culturally inclusive perspective becomes evident in the episodes featuring guests like Vicky Tsai, where rich discussions about culture and heritage emerge. These moments shine, suggesting how impactful it could be to similarly feature Black culinary voices, especially given the strong support for Sussex from Black women who have championed her struggles against racism.
Sussex could break conventional lifestyle brand molds by providing platforms to diverse voices, especially considering the ongoing underrepresentation within cooking shows. Although some may argue that the lack of diverse representation is a result of prevailing industry challenges, the opportunity presents itself far too elegantly given Netflix’s backing and the warm reception of her previous projects.
It’s noteworthy that while Sussex faces critics, including those responding harshly due to race or royal residuals, she simultaneously garners robust support from Black women across social media who align their own experiences with her narrative. This reflects broader dialogues surrounding the representation of Black women following African American history and systemic challenges and desires for validation in public life.
Despite the gaps, Sussex has achieved a measure of success that has not necessarily hinged upon championing Black women’s stories, highlighting systemic disparities that benefit her within a culture that often marginalizes others. The same systems that exposed her to intense scrutiny become the shields that guard her against critique concerning her inclusivity.
As a figure of immense cultural complexity, Sussex embodies a contradictory archetype—a domestic icon who both embraces and sidesteps racial narrative constraints. She presents herself as a lifestyle guru, yet her programming navigates the tension inherent in her dual identities—her royal lineage and her entrepreneurial aspirations.
The core questions linger: will Sussex fully engage with this opportunity while remaining authentic to her audience, and how will the public react to her evolving narrative?
As a prominent public figure shaped by relentless media scrutiny, four compounded by her racial identity and the complexities of her royal connections, she now finds herself at a crossroads between maintaining her authenticity and adapting to audience expectations amid her lifestyle branding endeavors.
Criticism toward Sussex stems from deeply rooted social and monarchist sentiments, as many harbor conflicted feelings about her status and success. The intertwined realities of wealth and race inevitably shape public discourse around her, particularly as she navigates her newfound role.
As she juggles her dual identities as a private individual and a public persona, juxtaposing her life in Montecito with her royal heritage, Sussex remains acutely aware of how her past continues to influence perceptions of her current endeavors.
The show emphasizes sustainability through relatable family-oriented themes, yet its ties to her privileged lifestyle could spur feelings of alienation among viewers. As public sentiments sway between admiration and resentment, the overarching narrative poses a critical inquiry about society’s aspirations amidst rising economic divides.
Meghan, Duchess of Sussex, presents a modern archetype that both challenges and aligns with historical expectations of female public figures. Engaged audiences want complexity, intimacy, and relatability, and they desire her to lead while remaining grounded. Regardless of external pressures, her choices in balancing public demands and her artistic vision will define her ongoing influence.
Her journey, fraught with public expectations and personal reinvention, underscores a significant evolutionary moment in lifestyle content creation. The balance between fulfilling her brand promise and navigating societal sensitivities will shape not just her narrative but the lifestyle genre for generations to come.
Source
www.eater.com