Photo credit: www.theguardian.com

The Substance: A Compelling Examination of Beauty and Horror

Upon contemplating the unsettling visuals within Coralie Fargeat’s latest film, “The Substance,” I found myself grappling with the equally disturbing imagery of two competing eyeballs inhabiting the same socket versus a more frenetic scene in which one eyeball produces multiple versions of itself. Ultimately, the former image left a deeper impact; its stark simplicity digs into your psyche, demanding a visceral reaction as opposed to the chaos of the latter that, while grotesque, has an air of absurdity that lessens its overall horror.

This initial unease serves as a prelude to a broader discussion surrounding the film’s central narrative, which follows the journey of Elisabeth Sparkle, portrayed by Demi Moore, a former Hollywood icon turned workout guru. As she embarks on a mysterious treatment in her pursuit of eternal youth and relevance, the plot unfurls in ways that invite varying interpretations. Some critics argue this ambiguity reflects the film’s shortcomings; if it serves as an allegory, then what precisely is its message? However, I found that liberating oneself from the need for definitive answers only enhances the film’s allure.

Prior to viewing “The Substance,” I had encountered significant buzz within my social circles, an unusual occurrence for someone whose feeds are typically crowded with sports analyses and political commentary. The film had evidently struck a chord, resonating with audiences both for its striking imagery and its thematic depth.

One provocative reading is that “The Substance” critiques consumerist culture, suggesting that the desire for physical perfection can warp an individual’s psyche and lead to self-destructive behavior. This perspective resonates with Fargeat’s intention to “explode the idea of beauty,” aiming to reflect on our authentic selves and our intrinsic struggles. The film invites viewers to explore a variety of interpretations, reflecting a nuanced take on societal expectations surrounding appearance.

The film’s visual storytelling contributes significantly to this discourse. From the opening shot featuring a cracked egg symbolizing flawed beauty to the eerie juxtaposition of Elisabeth’s life-sized photograph in her home — positioned like an idol or trophy — the imagery is as memorable as it is provocative. The stark contrast between Elisabeth’s reality and the corporate-sponsored ideal, represented by the billboard of her perfect alter ego, Sue, speaks volumes about the commodification of beauty and identity.

With its heart-pounding visuals and audacious content, “The Substance” stands out in its bold execution, challenging conventional representations of horror and beauty. Few films manage to blend memorable visuals with a tangential narrative so effectively, approaching themes of body horror and societal pressure with a unique lens.

Notably, the film features outstanding performances, especially from Moore, whose portrayal is being hailed as career-defining, and Margaret Qualley, whose role has captivated audiences. Historical contexts also lend weight, as “The Substance” has the potential to be the first horror film to contend for the prestigious Best Picture award, challenging the narrative that only traditional dramas hold merit at award shows.

As “The Substance” invites its viewers to reflect on its myriad influences, from nods to “The Shining” to elements that evoke the surreal style of David Lynch, it ignites memories of genre-defining films of the past. Personal reflections often lead back to cult classics that embrace chaos and grotesqueness, reminiscent of the iconic style of Peter Jackson.

A multitude of reasons exists to champion “The Substance” for Hollywood’s top honors. Yet, one must also face the reality of its chances; as a horror film helmed by a female director, it is unlikely to receive the accolades it deserves within an industry that often overlooks genre films. Regardless, “The Substance” is poised to leave an indelible mark, resonating within the minds of its audience and carving a niche in the cultural discourse. Its impact, both viral and cerebral, continues to expand, defining it as an artistic exploration that transcends traditional horror narratives.

Source
www.theguardian.com