Photo credit: www.higheredjobs.com
The Impact of Gender Perceptions on Academic Performance in Statistics
The Big Idea
Recent research reveals an intriguing dynamic in statistics education: female students tend to outperform their male counterparts academically, despite harboring more negative self-perceptions regarding their mathematical abilities. This finding emerges from a study published in the Journal of Statistics and Data Science Education.
The study analyzed data from over 100 students enrolled in various statistics classes. Researchers, including myself and my colleague, sought to uncover gender-related differences in academic performance throughout the semester. Participants provided insights through surveys administered at the beginning and end of the semester, addressing key areas such as their fear of statistics teachers, perceptions of the subject’s usefulness, personal assessments of mathematical abilities, and levels of anxiety related to exams and interpretations of statistical data. In addition, the surveys gauged students’ willingness to seek help.
Findings highlighted a correlation between negative self-assessments in mathematics and lower academic achievements. Notably, although initial exam scores for both genders were comparable, by the semester’s end, female students achieved nearly a 10% higher average on their final exams. This outcome is particularly striking given that women began the semester with significantly lower self-rated mathematical abilities compared to their male peers.
At the semester’s outset, women reported lower confidence in their mathematical skills along with heightened anxiety concerning exams and data interpretation. However, these self-assessments improved significantly, with their attitudes aligning more closely to those of their male classmates by the end of the term.
Conversely, male students who expressed anxiety towards statistics teachers or reluctance to seek assistance saw a sharper decline in grades throughout the semester. While improvements in attitude among these male students did correlate with better academic performance, the extent of this improvement did not match that of their female counterparts.
Why This Matters
Research consistently indicates that boys and girls have comparable math learning capabilities from an early age. Yet, disparities in classroom experiences persist. For example, studies show that girls are less frequently called on in math classes compared to boys, even when raising their hands equally. Additionally, there is evidence suggesting that some educators may grade female students’ assessments more stringently than those of their male peers. These factors can contribute to a growing perception among women, as they progress through their education, that they are less skilled in mathematics than men, affecting their likelihood of pursuing careers in STEM fields—science, technology, engineering, and mathematics.
Our study corroborates previous research by reinforcing the idea that women can excel in STEM disciplines, including statistics, and underscores the importance of mentoring for women as they embark on STEM-related educational pathways.
Unanswered Questions
While our findings shed light on some factors contributing to the gender gap in perceived mathematical ability, significant questions remain. For instance, what drove the positive shift in attitudes for the women in our study? Was this change attributable to an increase in self-confidence correlating with improved performance, or did the encouragement and teaching methods of their statistics instructors play a pivotal role?
Further investigation is needed to unravel the differences in how male and female students perceive their abilities over the course of an academic term. Specifically, understanding which elements of classroom dynamics or instructor behaviors foster more favorable attitudes could ultimately lead to enhanced student performance across genders.
Source
www.higheredjobs.com